ZackF
Puritan Board Professor
Beloved,
First, let me say that I don't buy into a lot of the sociological concepts surrounding racism and claims of systemic injustice and the manner in which "white privilege" is often defined.
That said, I think we need to wrestle more deeply with racial divisions that are not all caused by racial agitators. There really was a time when there was overt systematic repression and that period was within this generation of America. The reverberations are not quickly healed by simply saying that we've just moved past that point.
I have to admit that I'm a bit of an outsider when it comes to understanding regional culture. I was born into a military family and never lived in one place for more than 6 years in my youth and then went off to college away from home in New York and was in the Marine Corps for another 21 years. I was in a bit of a bubble being in the military Sure, I saw racist attitudes in some relatives and witnessed some things in my years in Texas that I didn't quite understand but I never really was culturally part of any region to speak of.
My reflexive attitude about racism has been that we've sort of moved beyond that but I don't think that it's healthy to ignore what the consequences of the past have left in terms of scars. As much as I'd like to think that I really know some of my black friends there are some things that I'm learning to detect and be sensitive to much the same way I'm sensitive to some of the cultural distinctiveness of my friends from the Middle East or the Far East.
I was smoking a cigar with a friend the other day who is a retired Air Force Staff NCO. He's a fine gentleman and we have a small group of us who enjoy fine cigars and conversation. The other day the topic of race came up and I asked him if he gets stopped regularly for no reason. He looked at me incredulously. He wasn't angry but it was sort of a look like - are you kidding. Later that night we were in a cigar lounge (OK, we like cigars) and he started to relate his childhood in North Carolina and how he is simply very wise even now about places he will go at night. There was a sign in a yard in his area that read: "Any colored people caught on this property after dark will be hung."
Now my friend will be the first to admit that the Air Force changed him. There's a certain enculturation in the Armed Forces that allows for camaraderie. In many ways, I wish that the Church was like that. We could all be enculturated in the Kingdom and then we would be able to talk freely in the same manner that many of us in the military can.
But you really need to study American Church History to see why this is not the case. It's not the fault of black people that the patterns of racial segregation emerged in America. It simply isn't. It's a really sad, sad history of how hard it was for the outcasts to be welcomed by the Church as full citizens in the visible Kingdom of God even when their educated clergy were urging for just that point. This experience left deep wounds and, unfortunately, I think it's why some of them turned to some extra-Biblical forms of justice that have shaped the trajectory of the continued division.
There are no easy answers here.
I'm reading a good book right now called Open Friendship in a Closed Society (http://amzn.to/1TX4bKM). I'm not advocating everything in the book but the story of how First Presbyterian Church in Jackson, MS (PCA) started to just talk and pray with ministers in the area is a beautiful story in light of the history of that region. When the shooting in Charleston, SC occurred, Rick Philips recounted how he went to pray and meet with black Churches in that area.
I guess what I'm saying is I've come to the point where I've stopped waiting for others to figure out where the good theology is and come to our Church and to go to where they are. There are some deep-seated fears and resentments that have been built up over the years. Yes, they have been exploited and exacerbated by people who do not have the true Gospel but, whatever the reason others might have to think ill of "white Churches", I've come to the conviction that I need to talk and pray with others in black Churches. No easy answers. I just want to do what I can to overcome some of these long-entrenched divisions.
To return to the OP, however, I think the idea that the Bible itself is racist because it was translated by white people is pure fiction and owes more to deconstructionist ideas about everyone having their own truth.
Very thoughtful and moving post. Thank you. I think I give up to easily sometimes. As my post above indicates, my struggle is figuring out how to NOT to be a racist correctly. Agitation in it's grassroots and academic form need not capture the heart of a believer and his love for a neighbor. It's silly to assume that human remedies for evil won't themselves be flawed, marked by sin, and self-righteousness. I remain in this and every other "issue", a work in progress.