Covenant Joel
Puritan Board Sophomore
I am trying to understand what Scripture says about baptism, and how much continuity there is between the old and the new covenants.
Jeremiah 31:31-34 is the prophecy of the New Covenant. It says, however, that the prophecy is for Israel and Judah. Dispensationalists obviously have a problem with this, because if we are in the New Covenant, then the church has inherited a promise made to Israel, and the Israel/Church distinction is wavering.
I am certainly not dispensational, and I do indeed see that the fulfillment of the New Covenant is indeed in the church. However, I am not certain as to the members of this New Covenant. This is my dilemma:
The opening verses of Romans 9 teach that "not all Israel is of Israel." In other words, not all who are ethnically part of the nation of Israel are truly Israel. For only those who are spiritually Jews are true Jews (Romans 2:28-29). So, true Israel is composed of those who are TRULY believers. In other words, as Galatians 3 puts it, "only those who are of faith are sons of Abraham." Only those who truly believe are children of Abraham, and are therefore true Israel.
Now if indeed the church is true Israel, the fulfillment of the typology of the ethnic nation of Israel in the Old Testament, then the church does not really include those who are not truly believers. And if this is the case, and the prophecy of the New Covenant is fulfilled in the True Israel, the Church, then how can we say that there are truly uncoverted people in that New Covenant?
And if no unconverted people are in the NC, then should babies be baptized?
Joel
Jeremiah 31:31-34 is the prophecy of the New Covenant. It says, however, that the prophecy is for Israel and Judah. Dispensationalists obviously have a problem with this, because if we are in the New Covenant, then the church has inherited a promise made to Israel, and the Israel/Church distinction is wavering.
I am certainly not dispensational, and I do indeed see that the fulfillment of the New Covenant is indeed in the church. However, I am not certain as to the members of this New Covenant. This is my dilemma:
The opening verses of Romans 9 teach that "not all Israel is of Israel." In other words, not all who are ethnically part of the nation of Israel are truly Israel. For only those who are spiritually Jews are true Jews (Romans 2:28-29). So, true Israel is composed of those who are TRULY believers. In other words, as Galatians 3 puts it, "only those who are of faith are sons of Abraham." Only those who truly believe are children of Abraham, and are therefore true Israel.
Now if indeed the church is true Israel, the fulfillment of the typology of the ethnic nation of Israel in the Old Testament, then the church does not really include those who are not truly believers. And if this is the case, and the prophecy of the New Covenant is fulfilled in the True Israel, the Church, then how can we say that there are truly uncoverted people in that New Covenant?
And if no unconverted people are in the NC, then should babies be baptized?
Joel