Non instrumental Worship?

Discussion in 'A capella Exclusive Psalmody' started by INsearch, Jan 25, 2010.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. INsearch

    INsearch Puritan Board Freshman

    I was wondering, how someone is able to justify only using your "voice" in regards to worshiping the Lord via music? my main questions stem from these verses.

    I ask respectfully how you are able to get past verses such as these? :worms:
     
  2. Prufrock

    Prufrock Arbitrary Moderation

    Joshua, without entering into a proper debate on the subject, the cause for refusing instruments in worship is briefly laid out below. If any one has anything to add or to augment this, please feel free.

    Under the Davidic and Temple worship, instruments were commanded. These instruments which accompanied the songs and were played in correlation with the sacrificial worship of the Old Testament could not be refused or neglected without deviating from the command of God. However, we see that this use of instruments was (1.) Positively instituted at a specific time, and (2.) Directly connected with the Temple worship and all its service. In the New Testament worship, (1.) With the temple service and all its appurtenances (including the command to use instruments) being abolished, and (2.) with no positive command given for the use of instruments, we do not use them in our public worship. Thus, such verses above do not present an "obstacle" to the non-instrumentalist, for they are understood in light of their position in the history of redemption: even as the Psalms also make mention of offering sacrifices of bulls, or going up to the temple, etc., which things the New Testament worshiper also does not do, so we are not troubled by the fact that the instruments which accompanied those same discontinued sacrifices have ceased (though we still sing with gladness and joy the Psalms that speak of them).

    The worshiper in the New Testament who does use instruments makes the case for their inclusion as a circumstance, not as an element of worship (i.e., that they either can be or cannot be, insofar as they serve to aid the proper element of singing, and so long as they are used properly, prudently and subordinately unto that end). The worshiper who refuses the instruments finds it difficult to allow that which was formerly a commanded element of worship (instruments) to now be a neutral circumstance.

    Again, I do not seek to debate a position, but I hope the body of non-instrumentalists on the board thinks this to be a fair summary of the position.
     
  3. INsearch

    INsearch Puritan Board Freshman

    Thank you for the summary. I myself wasn't going to be doing very much debating unless something occurred to me. I am going to read any reasons and scriptures given forth to consider them, and I of course will assume that those who'm don't think non-instrumental Worship music is vital will probably pop in with a counter argument of sorts ;) I learn good this way, I am able to see both positions at the same time and where they differ and such. However it doesn't occur to me atm any specific "musical" requirement in worshiping the Lord ever being mentioned in the NT, I could be wrong tho. Thanks for the summary.
     
  4. Backwoods Presbyterian

    Backwoods Presbyterian Puritan Board Doctor

    I have always found it curious that Paul in all his exhortations when it comes to things like spiritual gifts and general church life in all his letters and in his words of counsel to Timothy and Titus never once mentions musical instruments or music in general. This is especially interesting considering the place of music and musical instruments in the cultures in which Paul was preaching and Timothy and Titus were shepherding.

    Realize this is an argument from silence but interesting nonetheless.
     
  5. Wayne

    Wayne Tempus faciendi, Domine. Staff Member

    Joshua:

    Paul has provided you with a good summary of that position. For a fuller account, see the work by John L. Girardeau, which is available online here.
     
  6. Idelette

    Idelette Puritan Board Graduate

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page