KJV vs. 1599 Geneva

Discussion in 'Translations and Manuscripts' started by sastark, Mar 5, 2008.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. sastark

    sastark Puritan Board Graduate

    This is a question mostly for those who prefer the King James Version: Now that the 1599 Geneva Bible is back in print, what is preventing you from using it as your version of choice instead of the KJV?

    I understand the preference of KJV over, say, the NIV or ESV. But what makes the KJV a better translation than the 1599 Geneva Bible?

    I'm curious to hear your answers. Thanks!
     
  2. LadyFlynt

    LadyFlynt Puritan Board Doctor

    Actually, I DO prefer the 1599 Geneva to the KJV and use it instead of the KJV.
     
  3. Coram Deo

    Coram Deo Puritan Board Junior

    :ditto:

    I use my 1599 everywhere and everyday...
     
  4. Backwoods Presbyterian

    Backwoods Presbyterian Puritan Board Doctor

    Another Book I need to buy...:lol:
     
  5. LadyFlynt

    LadyFlynt Puritan Board Doctor

    :lol: ya'll must've missed the G1599Only thread.
     
  6. Coram Deo

    Coram Deo Puritan Board Junior

    :lol:


     
  7. sastark

    sastark Puritan Board Graduate


    Same here, I was just curious if anyone uses the KJV instead of the 1599GB and if so, what are their reasons.
     
  8. KMK

    KMK Moderator Staff Member

    You are asking two different questions: Why do I use the KJV instead of the Geneva? and What makes the KJV a better translation.

    As to the latter question I do not have the expertise to answer. (Although I think it is generally accepted that the KJV was an improvement on the Geneva)

    I use the KJV more than the Geneva for reasons other than translation. Mainly because it was the 'Standard' English version for many years while the Geneva drifted into obscurity. I believe the will continue to be the standard English version years from now. (We will have to wait and see).
     
  9. LadyFlynt

    LadyFlynt Puritan Board Doctor

    The KJV was a Reaction to the Geneva. If you think it was an Improvement, how?
     
  10. VirginiaHuguenot

    VirginiaHuguenot Puritanboard Librarian

    I love the 1599 Geneva Bible and I refer to it as needed. I prefer the KJV for a variety of reasons. It is the Bible used in the pulpit at my church. I think it is an improvement over the Geneva in many places. Its language flows better, imo, and for memorization purposes, the KJV is superior and also, for memorization purposes, incorporated into the Westminster Standards. The Geneva Notes are very good (especially Junius on Revelation), but I do differ from them in a few places. My 1599 Geneva by Tolle Lege doesn't have the Geneva Psalter in the back (although it's on the CD); my 1599 Geneva facsimile does, but it's not that useful practically for singing, for me, anyway; whereas, my KJV does have the 1650 Psalter in the back. So my reasons generally are, I think the KJV translation work is generally superior (though I love the Geneva Bible), and there are practical reasons why it's better for me to make the KJV my primary version. I don't have time to elaborate for now, but will come back to this thread later if need be. Meanwhile, Matthew Poole notes:

     
  11. AV1611

    AV1611 Puritan Board Senior

    I use the KJV because I have used the KJV since I was converted, love it and see no need to switch from the best version available.
     
  12. AV1611

    AV1611 Puritan Board Senior

    Not entirely, the dislike of the GB was really to do with its notes as is fairly clear historically. Not least because one of the rules from King James I was

    14. These translations to be used, when they agree better with the text than the Bishops’ Bible. TYNDAL’S, COVERDALE’S, MATTHEWS’S, WHITCHURCH’S, GENEVA.​

    http://www.trinitarianbiblesociety.org/site/articles/kings.pdf
     
  13. LadyFlynt

    LadyFlynt Puritan Board Doctor

    Okay, someone found a KJV WITH a Psalter?! Given Andrew, I shouldn't be shocked. And I agree, the facsimile is so much better...but how many people have $200-$300 to spend LOL!
     
  14. VirginiaHuguenot

    VirginiaHuguenot Puritanboard Librarian

    Colleen, re the KJV w/Psalter, all the PRC pew Bibles are KJV w/Psalters. They are published by the Trinitarian Bible Society. See also this thread:

    http://www.puritanboard.com/f63/av-metrical-psalms-29965/
     
  15. David_A_Reed

    David_A_Reed Puritan Board Freshman

    I'm currently reading a 1560 Geneva facsimile -- started in Revelation, with an interest in reading the notes. Is the 1599 Geneva just more widely available? Or do many find it preferable to the 1560?
     
  16. VirginiaHuguenot

    VirginiaHuguenot Puritanboard Librarian

    Both are available at Amazon and such places. I can't speak for all, but my thoughts on the two versions may be found here:

    http://www.puritanboard.com/f63/1560-vs-1599-geneva-bibles-24151/
     
  17. SueS

    SueS Puritan Board Freshman

    I just ordered my Geneva Bible from Monergism Books. The price is much better than Tolle Lege ($55) and the shipping is VERY reasonable - $3.99 for the Bible as well as another book I ordered. It will become my at home study Bible since I prefer a smaller volume for use at church.
     
  18. sastark

    sastark Puritan Board Graduate

    For those of you who have said the KJV is a better translation in some places, could you please provide examples? or point me to a web site that lists differences in the translations? Thank you!
     
  19. AV1611

    AV1611 Puritan Board Senior

    I don't think that anyone is saying that the KJV is better with regards to its translation as such (correct me if I am wrong). The difference is not between Beer and Malt Whisky but rather between a Balvenie and Laphroaig, one of taste. Which reminds me.....

    If you want to parrallel them then you can download them from e-sword!

    One example on Romans 6:1

    KJV: "What shall we say then? Shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound?"

    GB: "What shall we say then? Shall we continue still in sinne, that grace may abounde? God forbid."
     
  20. Grymir

    Grymir Puritan Board Graduate

    Hi Sastark! And everyone!

    I am torn between two lovers! The 1599 Geneva and KJV! Wife got me the Geneva for X-mas. I really like it. It seems just about the same as the King Jimmy in translation quality and the sources. I love how the NT face plate says "Translated out of Greek by Theodore Beza"! That is unbeatable!!

    However, I teach Sunday School in Church. I use the KJV there. When I took my Geneva to show it off, nobody ever heard of it. Of course, the NIV is the pew bible. :barfy: If you use the KJV at church, it's almost a silent sign to us real Reformed folk of who we are. (Kind of like a secret Mason handshake :lol:). My class is used to me using the KJV, and I don't want to confuse the poor souls anymore than they already are. I believe also that one translation should be used and read by one person in a classroom. (ME!!)

    So there you have it. I hope this helps. I could go on, but I think I've hit the highlights. (I'm beginning to sound like a modern praise band though. I. I. I.)
     
    Last edited: Mar 6, 2008
  21. Grymir

    Grymir Puritan Board Graduate

    Oh yea, I almost forgot. I'm thinking of nicknaming my Geneva - The Heap Bible

    II Tim 4:3 - "For the time will come when they will not suffer wholesome doctrine: but having their ears itching, shall after their own lusts get them an heap of teachers."

    :rofl:

    Ya gotta love this stuff. It appears elsewhere to!
     
  22. DMcFadden

    DMcFadden Moderator Staff Member

    Oh my! The KJV as shibboleth??? What if someone is carrying a Scofield KJV?
     
    Last edited: Mar 6, 2008
  23. Grymir

    Grymir Puritan Board Graduate

    That they were Left Behind by the PCUSA!! :rofl:
     
  24. DMcFadden

    DMcFadden Moderator Staff Member

    Try using a Geneva Bible in the PCUSA and you'll see who gets "left behind."

    (BTW--my sweat pants have the logo for "Left Behind" printed on, well, er, ah . . . you know . . . the Left . . . Behind. My 16 year old daughter will not let me wear them in public. Oh well!)
     
  25. Grymir

    Grymir Puritan Board Graduate

    (BTW--my sweat pants have the logo for "Left Behind" printed on, well, er, ah . . . you know . . . the Left . . . Behind. My 16 year old daughter will not let me wear them in public. Oh well!)

    :rofl: :lol: That's great. I wanna pair to wear to Church!!!!

    Yea, I take enough heat at my church for using KJV (Oh come on Tim, you wanna be relevent, or understood, or whatever don't you? They say, But I don't budge nor buy those lines either. If you can't stand the heat, don't use the KJV! :D). At least mine is conservative. But there 'reform' efforts are wayyyy to liberal for me. I couldn't imagine doing it at a mainstream PCUSA church.
     
  26. Thomas2007

    Thomas2007 Puritan Board Sophomore

    Seth,

    I don't have a lot of time tonight, so I'll give you three main reasons, but without a lot of explanation.

    1. Sola Scriptura - The doctrine of Scripture Alone as final authority has always included the Regula Fidei (Rule of Faith) of the Church, so while the Scripture alone is authoritative, it is never actually alone because the doctrines it teaches are part of it, which leads me to 2;

    2. Confessionalism - For surety of my faith, I need to maintain both theological and epistemological continuity between Scripture and the Confession in my adherence to Sola Scripture. The Authorized Version was the final form of the Reformation Bibles, likewise the Westminster Confession was the final form of the Reformation Confessions. They are a unity.

    3. Juridical Authority - The Authorized Version provides historical and legal continuity between law and gospel whereby I can better obey my Lord and serve Him in both body and spirit which were purchased by His blood. (e.g., 1 Cor 6:20) "For ye are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God's." Personally, I cherish this part because while I am grateful for the faith God has given me and the assurance of salvation that goes with that, I long to live for Him in a comprehensive sense, not just believe and trust in Him in a compartment that is segregated away into my private life, but publicly proclaim His name as being above every other without having my voice molested whereby I can lead a quite and peaceable life. So, if needs be I want to be able to defend that, which the Authorized Version provides me as an American - so it's more important to me than the Bill of Rights because they too have a continuity in terms of the Public Confession of Faith that is imputed unto me as a citizen.

    It is, then, this comprehensive genuine catholicity that binds me to the Authorized Version.

    Answering your question could be developed into a small treatise on the subject, so thanks for asking it, but these are the big three for me.

    Cordially,

    Thomas
     
  27. AV1611

    AV1611 Puritan Board Senior

    I still take mine to church with me...:lol:
     
  28. Galatians220

    Galatians220 Puritan Board Post-Graduate

    "Scofield KJV" - them's fightin' words in some parts, ain't they? :wink:

    Seriously, though, I bought my 1599 Geneva early last summer after already having acquired the 1560 version a couple of years ago. For awhile, I've been pretty stuck on the 1599GB except for the fact that its print is very small for someone with my eye problems to read. So I bought a nice magnifying glass to go along with it. Then I started comparing verses & didn't quite know what to think. To wit (just a couple of examples here for brevity's sake): 2 Corinthians 2:17 and Isaiah 26:3. I understand the subtleties of the different wording in the verse in 2 Corinthians and am cool with it, but the Isaiah 26:3 difference, I don't understand.

    I've been studying the "critical text/Textus Receptus" issue for about 9 years now and have come down finally, firmly and for all time (after 4 years of resistance) on the side of the KJV/Textus Receptus.

    Been going back and forth between my giant print KJV and the 1599GB lately; I do very much like the latter and would like it better if it came out in a giant print edition. If I'm wrong in preferring the KJV rendering of the two verses I mentioned above, I would like to hear about it... I'm still learning and have never been in a graduate theology course (except at the University of Detroit - and obviously, that doesn't count! :tombstone: - or not! - to that "education").
     
  29. etexas

    etexas Puritan Board Doctor

    :lol: Nice!
     
  30. JohnOwen007

    JohnOwen007 Puritan Board Sophomore

    So your wife is left out?

    :cool:
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page