I don't have time now, won't for at least a day (Presbytery), to address any particular questions addressed to me. I will try later.
Let me just say this: instead of wrangling over the finer points of observance, and using one's conclusions on that to decide whether one ought to consider the moral propriety of Sabbath observance, it would be better to settle the question of whether the law of Sabbath is moral in nature or not. And only afterward, decide questions of application.
Bill, that is my super-short (for reasons of time) answer to your whole post, I will get back to it. But the short point is: the day of rest is Moral in nature, not ceremonial. The manner of observance was part of the OT levitical dictation for the Israelites. Strip away that which was positive under the Old Covenant administration, add the new positive (change of day), and what is left is permanent, moral law.
Peace, brethren.
Let me just say this: instead of wrangling over the finer points of observance, and using one's conclusions on that to decide whether one ought to consider the moral propriety of Sabbath observance, it would be better to settle the question of whether the law of Sabbath is moral in nature or not. And only afterward, decide questions of application.
Bill, that is my super-short (for reasons of time) answer to your whole post, I will get back to it. But the short point is: the day of rest is Moral in nature, not ceremonial. The manner of observance was part of the OT levitical dictation for the Israelites. Strip away that which was positive under the Old Covenant administration, add the new positive (change of day), and what is left is permanent, moral law.
Peace, brethren.