John Duncan on the philosophy of Thomas Carlyle

Discussion in 'Philosophy' started by Reformed Covenanter, Sep 28, 2019.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Reformed Covenanter

    Reformed Covenanter Puritanboard Commissioner

  2. Reformed Covenanter

    Reformed Covenanter Puritanboard Commissioner

    BTW, do you prefer just a link to a blog post or would you prefer the link and the contents quoted below? I think it is easier to read stuff on the blog as you do not need to narrow the browser to read it easily, but some may prefer just to read stuff on PB.
     
  3. PuritanCovenanter

    PuritanCovenanter Moderator Staff Member

    At least a good teaser. What trousers? N. B.?
     
  4. jwright82

    jwright82 Puritan Board Graduate

    I never heard of him until now, thanks for sharing! In reading about him it would appear he was a man of his time. He influenced Nietzsche so there you go. People say he influenced Nazism but that's kinda an empty argument.
     
  5. PuritanCovenanter

    PuritanCovenanter Moderator Staff Member

    John Duncan on the philosophy of Thomas Carlyle
    [​IMG]

    CARLYLE. I am no worshipper of Force. I see nothing to admire in mere power, i.e. in its quantity apart from its quality. Carlyle’s earnestness is very touching and noble; but it seems to me that, according to his teaching, if you could conceive an omnipotent devil, you ought to worship him as much as Israel’s Jehovah. [So that he is in one sense a modem Manichee?] I suspect so. And an omnipotent militia of darkness would be the very horror of horrors. . .

    The connection between Carlylism and despotism I see, but the link is nowhere explicitly avowed. Carlyle is sometimes difficult to understand, and very difficult to judge. Why did he call Chalmers the last of the Christians? I suppose he forgets what he has written elsewhere. Hero-worship! ah well, he and I have to meet a strange hero yet … the greatest that I know of next to Him who overcame him. Carlyle has great faith in the devil, but I suspect he always appreciates quantity of being and of power more than quality....

    Click on the link to finish reading the quote.
     
  6. Reformed Covenanter

    Reformed Covenanter Puritanboard Commissioner

    He seems to be wearing tartan trousers or is it a kilt? :flamingscot:
     
  7. Reformed Covenanter

    Reformed Covenanter Puritanboard Commissioner

    I came across the reference quoted in the blog post in a history book that I am reading. The authors stated that John Duncan hated Thomas Carlyle's philosophy for the same reason that Adolf Hitler loved it. So, I do not think that we should dismiss the argument as a complete reductio ad Hitlerium - especially as Carlyle's racial prejudices were very strong.
     
  8. Reformed Covenanter

    Reformed Covenanter Puritanboard Commissioner

    You would refer to them as "pants", which is disconcerting to us Brits. ;)
     
  9. jwright82

    jwright82 Puritan Board Graduate

    I bet Hitler cried himself to sleep (genocide will do that to you). But thanks for introducing me to someone I never heard of, like your other posts. Keep up the good work.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page