James White and Doug Wilson
- Thread starter Scott Bushey
- Start date
- Status
In case others did not get this comment from the Reformed Catholic folks who think Wilson was too hard on Papists:
http://www.reformedcatholicism.com/archives/000435.htm
http://www.reformedcatholicism.com/archives/000435.htm
RamistThomist
Puritanboard Clerk
Thanks for the link. The replies to it are quite fun to read. Here is one statement that Wilson made that I am trying to figure his position on:
"It is nevertheless still my position that what happened at Trent deserved removal from the olive tree, that is, from the catholic church. But I am now convinced that such a removal has not yet occurred. God does not always give us what we deserve."
Well, were they removed or not? Who removed them? Since Trent anathematized the gospel, why didn't God remove them?
Maybe I am mis-reading Wilson.
However, I might encourage you all to get the debates at CMF, as their shipping rates are usually cheaper. That is just my experience comparing them and AOmin.
"It is nevertheless still my position that what happened at Trent deserved removal from the olive tree, that is, from the catholic church. But I am now convinced that such a removal has not yet occurred. God does not always give us what we deserve."
Well, were they removed or not? Who removed them? Since Trent anathematized the gospel, why didn't God remove them?
Maybe I am mis-reading Wilson.
However, I might encourage you all to get the debates at CMF, as their shipping rates are usually cheaper. That is just my experience comparing them and AOmin.
Scott Bushey
Puritanboard Commissioner
$3.00 to download.
RamistThomist
Puritanboard Clerk
This is a good debate, the thesis of it notwithstanding. Although i am a little more sympathetic to Wilson than most, James White is a POWERFUL debater. I am blown away! Also, I think Wilson has improved over the years since his Dan Barker debate.
Secondly,
I like AOMIN's way of downloading much better than Covenant Media. It is so much more convenient.
Secondly,
I like AOMIN's way of downloading much better than Covenant Media. It is so much more convenient.
Ianterrell
Puritan Board Sophomore
Anyone who has heard Wilson knows he is not a debater, or an orator. I'm interested in the content of the debate, but not sure if I want to hear this. White is obviously going to be persuasive in this format.
- Status
