CharlieJ
Puritan Board Junior
Note: This was originally a Facebook post for some of my friends, which I intended not only to articulate my struggle, but to encourage others. I offer it up here for the same reasons, and for any advice my PB brothers (and sisters) may have.
-----
I assume that all of us sometimes encounter difficulties in our Bible study, or encounter people from different Christian traditions that hold ideas that seem utterly alien. Other than just shrugging your shoulders and dismissing it, what do you do about it? Especially when people you care about – smart, godly, great people – seem to be pulling you in different directions, how do you tell what is really true?
I am now facing the most difficult doctrine that I have ever had to grapple with in my Christian walk. It is also a relatively significant doctrine that would affect my ability to be ordained or teach in certain denominations. The issue I am considering is baptism, whether it is for regenerate professors of faith only (credobaptism) or whether the children of believers are proper recipients of the sacrament (covenantal paedobaptism).
The overriding concern is the pursuit of truth. Sometimes motivations such as vindicating yourself and others, or reducing tension between family and friends can interfere with a wholehearted pursuit of truth. It must be constantly remembered that Christ alone is Lord, and that His Word and approval are worth more than the affirmation of any other.
The pursuit of truth takes time. The psychological pressure of being uncertain may cause you to seek a quick, easy, or convenient answer; but this is not the way of discipleship. Christ calls us to a lifetime of following, not easy resting.
I have outlined below how I plan to resolve this issue, in the hope that it may provide help to someone who is facing or will face a difficult doctrinal issue at some time.
Read the Bible Through Again Entirely
Often a Bible difficulty cannot be solved directly. Bible doctrines are interconnected, and an understanding of the whole can greatly help the comprehension of a part. Plus, it simply gives more time for meditation and maturity.
Continue to Repent of Sin and Seek Holiness
Reading Calvin’s Institutes and John Frame’s The Doctrine of the Knowledge of God has impressed upon me that obedience to God is a prerequisite for greater understanding. Romans 1 details how a group of people who knew some things about God rejected their knowledge, and God abandoned them to ignorance. Colossians 1:10 connects the knowledge of God with bearing fruit for him. So, it seems that the way to a deeper knowledge of God is through a deeper relationship with Him.
Study the History of the Controversy
A lot of things make more sense when viewed in their historical contexts. At the same time, you encounter a lot of great people and ideas from church history and broaden your understanding of Christianity and what God has done in the world before you entered it.
Study the Surrounding Doctrines
Again, Christian doctrine is all interconnected. So, seeing how one idea bumps up against others can help give the entire issue shape. For example, baptism is connected to the Lord’s Supper, the New Covenant, and the nature of the church.
Consider the Best Arguments
It can be very appealing to read one side of an issue and nod at the “unassailable” arguments. The pursuit of truth, however, compels us to understand an issue so well that we would be able to present each side in a way that proponents of that side would recognize and approve.
Pray
Wisdom comes from God, yes? (See Proverbs for answer).
Finally, even at the end, we have to be willing to say “I don’t know” and repeat the process. The Bible is a big book, and even taking college or seminary courses doesn’t allow us to absorb that kind of knowledge in a short span of time.
I hope this helps someone who may be going through some difficulties or just critical thinking. Pray for me as I seek to grow in knowledge!
-----
I assume that all of us sometimes encounter difficulties in our Bible study, or encounter people from different Christian traditions that hold ideas that seem utterly alien. Other than just shrugging your shoulders and dismissing it, what do you do about it? Especially when people you care about – smart, godly, great people – seem to be pulling you in different directions, how do you tell what is really true?
I am now facing the most difficult doctrine that I have ever had to grapple with in my Christian walk. It is also a relatively significant doctrine that would affect my ability to be ordained or teach in certain denominations. The issue I am considering is baptism, whether it is for regenerate professors of faith only (credobaptism) or whether the children of believers are proper recipients of the sacrament (covenantal paedobaptism).
The overriding concern is the pursuit of truth. Sometimes motivations such as vindicating yourself and others, or reducing tension between family and friends can interfere with a wholehearted pursuit of truth. It must be constantly remembered that Christ alone is Lord, and that His Word and approval are worth more than the affirmation of any other.
The pursuit of truth takes time. The psychological pressure of being uncertain may cause you to seek a quick, easy, or convenient answer; but this is not the way of discipleship. Christ calls us to a lifetime of following, not easy resting.
I have outlined below how I plan to resolve this issue, in the hope that it may provide help to someone who is facing or will face a difficult doctrinal issue at some time.
Read the Bible Through Again Entirely
Often a Bible difficulty cannot be solved directly. Bible doctrines are interconnected, and an understanding of the whole can greatly help the comprehension of a part. Plus, it simply gives more time for meditation and maturity.
Continue to Repent of Sin and Seek Holiness
Reading Calvin’s Institutes and John Frame’s The Doctrine of the Knowledge of God has impressed upon me that obedience to God is a prerequisite for greater understanding. Romans 1 details how a group of people who knew some things about God rejected their knowledge, and God abandoned them to ignorance. Colossians 1:10 connects the knowledge of God with bearing fruit for him. So, it seems that the way to a deeper knowledge of God is through a deeper relationship with Him.
Study the History of the Controversy
A lot of things make more sense when viewed in their historical contexts. At the same time, you encounter a lot of great people and ideas from church history and broaden your understanding of Christianity and what God has done in the world before you entered it.
Study the Surrounding Doctrines
Again, Christian doctrine is all interconnected. So, seeing how one idea bumps up against others can help give the entire issue shape. For example, baptism is connected to the Lord’s Supper, the New Covenant, and the nature of the church.
Consider the Best Arguments
It can be very appealing to read one side of an issue and nod at the “unassailable” arguments. The pursuit of truth, however, compels us to understand an issue so well that we would be able to present each side in a way that proponents of that side would recognize and approve.
Pray
Wisdom comes from God, yes? (See Proverbs for answer).
Finally, even at the end, we have to be willing to say “I don’t know” and repeat the process. The Bible is a big book, and even taking college or seminary courses doesn’t allow us to absorb that kind of knowledge in a short span of time.
I hope this helps someone who may be going through some difficulties or just critical thinking. Pray for me as I seek to grow in knowledge!