Northern Crofter
Puritan Board Sophomore
For those of us who subscribe to the The Directory for the Publick Worship of God, this is consistent.“For those who reject Xmas as a holy day”.. anyone here celebrating Christmas in the privacy of their own home obviously rejects it as a holy day. It’s not the Lord’s Day (and if it falls on the Lord’s Day like this year we must not change our Sabbath routines).
Many here also celebrate birthdays and Thanksgiving, those aren’t holy days either. You seem to be arguing that it’s not a matter of private liberty, which is challenging if you endeavor to be consistent with virtually any other “holiday”.
First, the Directory positively endorses observing public and private celebrations of Thanksgiving (see the section titled "Of the Observation of Days of Publick Thanksgiving" - the private celebration is mentioned in this paragraph: "But the minister (before their dismission) is solemnly to admonish them to beware of all excess and riot, tending to gluttony or drunkenness, and much more of these sins themselves, in their eating and refreshing; and to take care that their mirth and rejoicing be not carnal, but spiritual, which may make God’s praise to be glorious, and themselves humble and sober; and that both their feeding and rejoicing may render them more cheerful and enlarged, further to celebrate his praises in the midst of the congregation, when they return unto it in the remaining part of that day.").
Second, it is difficult to see how one would conflate celebrating birthdays as "Festival days" or (so-called) "Holy-day" as prohibited by the DPW: "Festival days, vulgarly called Holy-days, having no warrant in the word of God, are not to be continued" ("Touching Days and Places for Publick Worship."). Thus both Christian liberty and prudence should govern the celebration of birthdays. There are limited examples of birthday celebrations in Scripture to choose from - only 2 I can think off: Genesis 40 (positive celebration?) and Matthew 14 (negative).
"THERE is no day commanded in scripture to be kept holy under the gospel but the Lord’s day, which is the Christian Sabbath" (DPW Appendix). Let us rejoice and be glad!