Flags in the sanctuary

Status
Not open for further replies.
larryjf

larryjf

Puritan Board Senior
The subject of flags being in our sanctuary came up at the last committee meeting.
Since reformed theology basically says that if God does not specify something for worship, it's not proper in worship - how would you argue for or against having a flag in the sanctuary?
 
It would probably be ok if it was a "Christian" flag :D:D:D

Oh, this isn't "The things you will never hear on the PB" thread is it.:banghead:
 
VirginiaHuguenot,

Thanks for the link, but there were only a couple of postings there before it turned into another conversation. So any further discussion would be appreciated.
 
Larry,

To be serious here, the first question I would ask is what is the primary purpose of the sanctuary? I suspect you'd get answers that are dependent on each individual situation. We worship in the student center and don't have a sanctuary per se. And yet when we gather for worship there is only one purpose for the building and indeed for us, and at that time I don't believe it is apporpriate to have symbols that might be construed as representing devided allegiences present. Just my humble opinion.
 
Originally posted by VirginiaHuguenot
Personally, flags in the sanctuary to me raise red flags! :D
Click to expand...
:up:

You have to look at why there there. My old church met in a gym. There were flags there but we couldn't do anything about it. But in a church building, they shouldn't be there at all. Honestly, I don't think there should be any decoration at all. I don't see how it contributes to facilitating worship.
 
Our congregation has merged with another congregation and their building will become our new facility.

One of our young people noticed that they had a both a US and "Christian" flag in the sancturary and asked the Session if they would be staying when we start worshipping there in late May.

Very perceptive.
 
My home church has British flags in it to honour the fact it's Scottish or something. My new church is so big that I haven't even noticed if there are flags (which means if there are, they must not be too distracting!).

Honestly, I'm just glad there isn't a gay flag in the sanctuary. Sounds like a ludicrous idea, but I saw it when I was shopping around for a church! It wasn't in the sanctuary, but over the door going in. It was like 2x3'! That's what I get for experimenting by going to a United Church. :barfy:
 
The U.S. government has this strange penchant for never raising the flag of a state over its office buildings... so why shouldn't churches operate the same way? Just a Christian flag...
 
Originally posted by WrittenFromUtopia
RPCNA churches display the Banner of the Covenant at the front of the church on the wall.
Click to expand...

Is there a Banner of the Covenant store out there on the Internet?
 
Originally posted by Puritanhead
Originally posted by WrittenFromUtopia
RPCNA churches display the Banner of the Covenant at the front of the church on the wall.
Click to expand...

Is there a Banner of the Covenant store out there on the Internet?
Click to expand...

No. Each congregation sews/makes their own. They're all unique.
 
Originally posted by WrittenFromUtopia
RPCNA churches display the Banner of the Covenant at the front of the church on the wall.
Click to expand...

In the sanctuary above the pulpit. Otherwise the church I attend is completely devoid of all ornamentation and painted white around every wall.
 
Originally posted by Peter
Originally posted by WrittenFromUtopia
RPCNA churches display the Banner of the Covenant at the front of the church on the wall.
Click to expand...

In the sanctuary above the pulpit. Otherwise the church I attend is completely devoid of all ornamentation and painted white around every wall.
Click to expand...

:ditto:
 
The issue seems too insignificant to mention, but I would like to see the banner moved to a back room.

[Edited on 9-10-2005 by Peter]
 
Yeah, I can see your point. If God graces me to be a pastor someday, I would likely not have it displayed above the pulpit (if that's an option? I don't know much about RPCNA politics yet).
 
I'm sure there's nothing forcing the congregation to keep the banner there. I always thought it was more of a tradition. I fully agree with the political message the banner symbolizes, just for worship issues I don't think we should be putting "decoration" in the sanctuary.
 
I've never been happy about it, but it seems to be the norm in Baptist churches unfortunately. In fact, the first time I visited a Baptist church with my wife (in the days before she was my wife) I complained about it. Didn't think it was appropriate then and still don't.
 
I am entirely against flags. We are all one in Christ, and that fact undermines any national or ethnic ties within the context of worship.
 
I don't believe the RPCNA banner has any national or ethnic ties. It stands for the kingdom/kingship of Christ and His superiority above all other kings and kingdoms.
 
Originally posted by WrittenFromUtopia
I don't believe the RPCNA banner has any national or ethnic ties. It stands for the kingdom/kingship of Christ and His superiority above all other kings and kingdoms.
Click to expand...

That's fine. I should have said "I am against all national flags." However I am not a fan of any decoration in the church since it tends to distract and lead the worshipper away from the preached word and sacraments.

I would therefore agree with you and Peter about putting the flag/banner in the back of the sanctuary.
 
It stands for the kingdom/kingship of Christ and His superiority above all other kings and kingdoms.
Click to expand...
There's just something about having a flag/banner that stands for a kingdom/kingship that the King Himself didn't establish - doesn't sit well with me.

We are going to try and move our flags to the back balcony. The funny thing is, when i told the Associate Pastor what was going on he didn't want to have to look at the flags while he preached!

When the actual move comes, i'll bet we will hear alot of grief because of it.
 
How are flags elements of worship? That's the issue here. Circumstances are not regulated by Scripture. I don't see how a flag is on a different level than pews.
 
Originally posted by rgrove
I've never been happy about it, but it seems to be the norm in Baptist churches unfortunately. In fact, the first time I visited a Baptist church with my wife (in the days before she was my wife) I complained about it. Didn't think it was appropriate then and still don't.
Click to expand...

Interesting, Ron, two Reformed Baptist churches I know of in the Seattle-Tacoma area don't have them. They don't have anything but a pulpit.

I don't like flags at a worship meeting either.

Vic
 
Agreed Vic, we're an exception to the rule with Baptists, though, it seems to me. I was was also being a little more generic in the term baptist. Go into most any Baptist church and the red, white and blue will be up front almost certainly. Just look at the "Justice Sunday" crowd. Think they wouldn't think less of us for protesting an American flag in the sanctuary?

[Edited on 9-10-2005 by rgrove]
 
Circumstances are not regulated by Scripture. I don't see how a flag is on a different level than pews.
Click to expand...
Pews are utilitarian in nature, flags tend to represent a loyalty to something or the authority of something.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

jawyman
  • Locked
  • Poll
Should flags be placed in the sanctuary?
2
Replies
41
Views
9K
Peairtach
Peairtach
A
  • Locked
Poll: American/"Christian" flags in YOUR particular sanctuary?
Replies
29
Views
3K
WrittenFromUtopia
W
MMasztal
  • Locked
"Chrismon" tree in the sanctuary
2
Replies
51
Views
12K
Scottish Lass
Scottish Lass
thistle93
  • Locked
American/Christian Flag in Sanctuary?
2
Replies
35
Views
9K
Mushroom
Mushroom
C
  • Locked
Scriptural argument against flags in worship
2
Replies
33
Views
12K
forgivenmuch
forgivenmuch
Back
Top