Favorite Secular Movie

Not open for further replies.


Tempus faciendi, Domine.
Of the more recent movies, O, Brother Where Art Thou?

Old movies: It Happened One Night; The Quiet Man;


Puritanboard Commissioner
I enjoy good propaganda films (but aren't they all, these days, if you leave off the qualifier 'good').

Soldier of Orange is worth the time. Wake Island. Lady Jane. Triumph of the Will (ending is a bit cheesy). Movies that everyone should see at least once would include Olympia 2 (Olympia 1 only for sports fans and cinema fans) and Birth of a Nation.


Puritan Board Freshman
Lord of the Rings: Return of the King is tied with Gettysburg for #1

But on the lighter side: Groundhog's Day

Southern Presbyterian

Puritan Board Doctor
I just happen to have a list...

The Top 26 Greatest Movies Ever Made are:

  1. Ride With The Devil
  2. The Princess Bride
  3. Serenity
  4. O Brother, Where Art Thou?
  5. A Christmas Story
  6. Signs
  7. The Shawshank Redemption
  8. The Lord of The Rings Trilogy
  9. Gods and Generals
  10. The Green Mile
  11. Tangled
  12. Ella Enchanted
  13. District 9
  14. Master And Commander
  15. Rustlers Rhapsody
  16. How to Train Your Dragon
  17. Aladdin
  18. Die Hard Series
  19. True Grit (1969)
  20. True Grit (2011)
  21. The Fifth Element
  22. Christmas Vacation
  23. Bicentennial Man
  24. Robin Hood: Men in Tights
  25. The Matrix Trilogy
  26. Groundhog Day


Puritan Board Sophomore
For me it would be the LOTR Trilogy (you can't separate them in my opinion). I also really like Saving Private Ryan, Gladiator, Troy & Braveheart.


Puritan Board Freshman
So many good movies mentioned! In fact my top 3 were already named....

Last of the Mohicans (the last 10 minutes of that movie alone are worth the price of admission!)


Staff member
Recently I have really enjoyed The King's Speech, Hugo, and The Muppet Movie which almost brought me to tears when the Muppet Show Theme Song came on. (I grew up on the Muppets)


Puritan Board Junior

My Top Five:

5) The Princess Bride
4) Pride and Prejudice (BBC version)
3) Le Miserables (Liam Neeson)
2) Nicholas Nickleby (2002)
1) The Matrix (Original)




Puritan Board Graduate
Two of my favorites are:


The Rocky Horror Picture Show. Ok some might not like this one.


Puritan Board Junior
The Good the Bad and the Ugly, Doctor Strangelove (most likely an unpopular choice), Unforgiven, and the Brave Little Toaster

Miss Marple

Puritan Board Junior
I had "Last of the Mohicans" in mind before I even read any responses. I am glad to see I am in good company.

"Hoodwinked," "Napoleon Dynamite," "Nacho Libre," "Elf," and the Pink Panther movies are all good funny movies.

I also loved "O Brother" and purchased the soundtrack, which is dynamite.


Snow Miser
I'm a big fan of the Shawshank Redemption. Tim Robbins' best movie in my opinion. The Green Mile is also excellent. 10 points to the person who knows who the author of these two gems is off the top of their head. ;)

The LOTR trilogy is obviously up there. I enjoy the Two Towers the most, with The Return of the King in second and The Fellowship of the Ring in third.

I enjoy the Matrix trilogy, but they got successively worse over time. The last one was watchable, but not great. The first one was outstanding and set the bar high for science fiction films for me. Since that time, few sci-fi films have really done it for me.

I'm happy to see Serenity on someone's list. Really enjoyed that movie. Highly underrated. I'd like to see further films made based on the Firefly storyline.

The Star Trek re-make. Top notch, and I'm not a Trekkie in the least. Maybe that's why I loved the movie.

Amistad is an outstanding movie. I didn't see it until a few years ago and I've gotta say it's great.

Going to catch flak for this but one of my favorite movies is The Watchmen. Should you watch this film though, get the edited version and be prepared to fast forward. Hollywood took an otherwise intriguing movie and made sure to add in completely unnecessary sexual garbage that literally adds nothing to the story line.

Dr. Strangelove is most certainly not an unpopular choice. A pristine example of black comedy.

There are others. Can't think of them right now.
Not open for further replies.