Best commentary series?

Discussion in 'Exegetical Forum' started by Supersillymanable, Jul 31, 2012.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Supersillymanable

    Supersillymanable Puritan Board Freshman

    Hey guys,

    I've recently been thinking about getting some commentary series. Essentially, I wanted a series that is more on the side of application, one that is more exegetical, and another that is more expositional (or is expositional pretty much the same as application? I thought it was the almost "in between" of the two). Any suggestions?

    I have the entire New testament BST, which I've really enjoyed. I also have access to the entire tyndale series, but found them very brief, which disappointed me somewhat. I also have access to all the old testament of BST. Though I have access to the Tyndale and BST (OT), I don't own them, they're my Dad's, and wanted to buy some commentaries of my own...

    Thanks!
     
  2. Bill The Baptist

    Bill The Baptist Puritan Board Graduate

  3. Marrow Man

    Marrow Man Drunk with Powder

    The Tyndale OT and NT series are pretty good for the layman and pastor. Good explanation of the text w/o getting bogged down too much in the details. The Reformed Expository Commentary series is pretty good as well. It's fairly new so the set (done by various modern authors) is incomplete. It is essentially derived from sermons preached by the individuals (so you get both exegetical comments as well as applications of the text). I have only read the volumes on 1 Kings (by Philip Ryken) and Acts (by Derek Thomas). The latter volume is excellent, btw.
     
  4. J. Dean

    J. Dean Puritan Board Junior

    I don't know how useful it would be for your purpose, but the CrossWay Commentary Series (edited by McGrath and Packer) is quite good. It draws from a variety of Reformed teachers (with Luther making a "guest" appearance for the book of Galatians). I'm going through Charles Hodge's commentary on Romans, and it's fantastic.

    Books | Crossway
     
  5. Jerusalem Blade

    Jerusalem Blade Puritan Board Post-Graduate

    I second the Hendriksen set as the best for the NT.
     
  6. jwithnell

    jwithnell Moderator Staff Member

    May I suggest you may be better served getting individual commentaries, assuming you want help in studying through books rather than make quick references, in which case a good study Bible may serve you more concisely? That way, you can benefit from the strengths of a particular commentator for a particular book, then re-evaluate as you start another study. I have found Amazon.com: A Guide to Biblical Commentaries & Reference Works (9780982871560): John Frederick Evans: Books to be especially helpful in making selections. John's reach exceeds my comfort zone in some cases -- he's trying to ensure that theological students know the major writers on various books -- but if he says a work is solid, you can bet the farm on it.
     
  7. jogri17

    jogri17 Puritan Board Junior

    1. Baker NT (Hendrickson/Kistemacher)
    2. The Bible Speaks Today: New Testament
    3. The Expositor's Bible Commentary
    4. Tyndale Commentaries
    5. The New Bible Commentary 1vol.
     
  8. Backwoods Presbyterian

    Backwoods Presbyterian Puritan Board Doctor

    Of the individual commentaries I use from sets the Tyndale Commentary series is consistently the best for sermon prep and I have even read them devotionally from cover-to-cover. They are very well put together.

    Also I really like the Welwyn series.
     
  9. moral necessity

    moral necessity Puritan Board Junior

    I've always appreciated Calvin's the most.

    You can also try the Geneva Series, if you want a conglomeration of authors. It's a little expensive, but you can usually find them one at a time fairly cheap and build a collection.

    Christianbook.com: Calvin's Commentaries, 22 Volumes/with bonus copy of Calvin's Institutes: John Calvin: 9780801013317

    Geneva Series of Commentaries Bundle (31 Volume Set) :: Geneva Commentaries :: Commentaries & Sermons :: Monergism Books :: Reformed Books - Discount Prices - Free Shipping


    Blessings in your studies...
     
  10. ADKing

    ADKing Puritan Board Junior

    Although it is older, as a commentary on the whole Bible, I still have never found anything that beats Matthew Henry. I use him every week as a pastor with great profit.
     
  11. Andres

    Andres Puritan Board Doctor

    I second this suggestion. For help in selecting commentaries, look no further than the board's own Rev Keister for recommendations. I've purchased several commentaries based on brother Lane's recommendations and have yet to be disappointed.
     
  12. arapahoepark

    arapahoepark Puritan Board Graduate

    Doesn't NT Wright have a couple commentaries in the Tyndale? Avoid those ones (that he wrote) at least.
     
  13. jogri17

    jogri17 Puritan Board Junior

    NT Wright is not some heretical buggyman, lex Luther kinda guy. He only does the Col.and Phil. volume, and he brings a cool perspective to it especially on Christological aspects. Justification isn't a major theme, and the Reformed confessions don't address the subject of Jesus' knowledge of his divinity within the human nature (whether he was always aware or became aware over time), so it's a fair point to hold (important on Col. 2).
     
  14. Somerset

    Somerset Puritan Board Junior

    The Metropolitan Tabernacle bookshop has the one volume Matthew Henry for £15 -50. This has very small print, is very heavy and does not have the words of the Bible included. I may have a spare copy of this - if interested let me know and I will have a look (no charge - collect from Sherwood). The six volume set, which includes the AV text, is £33. The Hendriksen set is £92-50 and Calvin's commentary set is £95 - including a copy of the Institutes, though not the translation most on this site seem to prefer. All books are hardback and postage is free over £40.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page