Is the yin-yang sign necessarily occultic?

Status
Not open for further replies.
RamistThomist

RamistThomist

Puritanboard Clerk
I don't have any of them and they aren't really the type of stuff I dig, but is the symbol necessarily occultic? I understand the Taoist use of some of them (harmony of opposites), but does it automatically imply concepts of "chi?"
 
It implies dualism. So it is wrong. But some see it as implying balance, which is not bad in some sense. I think it goes along with Chi.

Many eastern people believe in these concepts. There is a spiritual aspect to it, but much of it is focused on mental/emotional health. I don't think all believers in chi or inner energy are believing in the occult any more than someone who believed in Galen's theory of the humors.
 
My thought is that the symbols are widely recognized as part of eastern philosophy. Why make the association with yourself?
 
jwithnell said:
My thought is that the symbols are widely recognized as part of eastern philosophy. Why make the association with yourself?
Click to expand...

I agree, but let's say you are a South Korean Christian, you bear the markings of something that looks a lot like it. Unless you are an Anabaptist South Korean, which removes some of the problem.
 
Pergamum said:
It implies dualism. So it is wrong.
Click to expand...

Eternal dualism or subordinate dualism? The former is obviously off limits, but the latter isn't. Christian orthodoxy demands body-soul dualism (sorry, Dooyeweerdians).

Of course, I don't want to read Christian categories into it, but I have studied Taoism a bit (I read the Tao Te Ching) and it admits of fluidity in interpretation.

Further, it's harmony of opposites sounds a lot like medieval Trinitarianism, where two relations of opposition produce a new Person.
 
BayouHuguenot said:
Eternal dualism or subordinate dualism? The former is obviously off limits, but the latter isn't. Christian orthodoxy demands body-soul dualism (sorry, Dooyeweerdians).

Of course, I don't want to read Christian categories into it, but I have studied Taoism a bit (I read the Tao Te Ching) and it admits of fluidity in interpretation.

Further, it's harmony of opposites sounds a lot like medieval Trinitarianism, where two relations of opposition produce a new Person.
Click to expand...
Or it sounds like Manicheanism, or the Force of Star Wars.
 
I like the Greek letter epsilon. ε

It's an engineering symbol for direct strain. The goal, at least in my life, is to maintain an even strain--which implies dynamic balance.
 
The modern Korean flag dates to 1880 and is based on the Joseon king's personal standard.

The red and blue circle (taegeuk), representing cosmic harmony and wholeness; red means positive forces, blue negative. It is, basically, a pagan symbol. (The symbol is strongly associated with Daoism, but Daoism has historically had very little actual impact on Korea.)

It's not the only one. Each of the trigrams towards the corners is a symbol used in divination. There are eight trigrams on the king's standard.

But few Koreans even know about that. The flag became prominent as a patriotic symbol in the days of Japanese colonial occupation (especially from the March First Movement of 1919). The only associations it has today are patriotic.
 
No. It simply symbolizes the interconnected nature of binary opposites into which Daoists and others who share a similar cosmology believe the world is organized (e.g., patterns of light and shadow, hot and cold, etc.), arising from the one.

In that sense, regardless of how it is used to day, it would probably be more accurate to consider it in terms of a philosophy or even a proto-science rather than something necessarily occult. Much like traditional Chinese medicine.
 
Pergamum said:
Jacob,

Interesting. Yes, that is right, isn't it.

How ancient do you think Manicheanism is?
Click to expand...

Manicheanism proper started around 230 AD with Manes. Zoroastrianism and other eternal dualisms are much, much older. The difference is that Zoroastrians don't necessarily see matter as evil simpliciter.

So, I misspoke on Manicheanism.
 
I'd say it's more pagan than occult. Regardless, it's not something Christians should associate with. Though I see nothing wrong if South Koreans use it in a purely patriotic way.
 
Like lots of other things philosophically, it gets some of our natural realities bestowed by our Creator fairly right and some pretty wrong. Like the philosophers and cultural ideologies so prevalent in Augustine’s day who were not as hostile to true religion but ultimately man centered in their belief and understanding...
Why do you ask? Don’t get the tattoo, lol
 
A.Joseph said:
Like lots of other things philosophically, it gets some of our natural realities bestowed by our Creator fairly right and some pretty wrong. Like the philosophers and cultural ideologies so prevalent in Augustine’s day who were not as hostile to true religion but ultimately man centered in their belief and understanding...
Why do you ask? Don’t get the tattoo, lol
Click to expand...

That's a pretty good way of putting it. My own tentative conclusions:

1) Although I practice Taekwon-do, I doubt I will be wearing yin yang headbands. Most of my clothing is utterly plain and boring.

2) I don't think it is necessarily wrong. Something isn't wrong because of its tainted past. That is the genetic fallacy. In that case, we should avoid coffee because it was discovered by Muslims. Modern day space technology relies on astronomy, which wouldn't have been possible without pagan astrology.

3) To the degree it has pagan roots, we should be cautious. Of course, I don't think it is any worse than the Neo-Platonic taints in Augustine's philosophy, and Neo-Platonism is basically Egyptian theurgic magick.
 
The symbols on the Korean flag are undoubtedly pagan in origin. But what do we say when those symbols have lost their meaning? Clearly, the flag isn't being used in for pagan worship. You won't find many (except maybe the odd shaman) who actually employs the trigrams for divination. (I don't know enough about fortune-telling to say.)

Today, shamanism and fortune-telling still have a hold over some older Koreans, but with the rise of Western-style secularism they are losing sway.

I don't think the flag is pagan or even a stumbling block to any Korean Christian. However, I imagine the taegeuk could bother some Western Christians. For that reason it might be better to avoid it.
 
BayouHuguenot said:
That's a pretty good way of putting it. My own tentative conclusions:

1) Although I practice Taekwon-do, I doubt I will be wearing yin yang headbands. Most of my clothing is utterly plain and boring.

2) I don't think it is necessarily wrong. Something isn't wrong because of its tainted past. That is the genetic fallacy. In that case, we should avoid coffee because it was discovered by Muslims. Modern day space technology relies on astronomy, which wouldn't have been possible without pagan astrology.

3) To the degree it has pagan roots, we should be cautious. Of course, I don't think it is any worse than the Neo-Platonic taints in Augustine's philosophy, and Neo-Platonism is basically Egyptian theurgic magick.
Click to expand...
Yeah, I mean there are plenty of cultural distinctions worldwide - as long as we don’t build our faith around it and it is not an offense to God.... look at the southerners and the confederate flag... I’m not sure where I’m going with this, lol ..... can I get a Jesus fish?
 
Tom Hart said:
The symbols on the Korean flag are undoubtedly pagan in origin. But what do we say when those symbols have lost their meaning? Clearly, the flag isn't being used in for pagan worship. You won't find many (except maybe the odd shaman) who actually employs the trigrams for divination. (I don't know enough about fortune-telling to say.)

Today, shamanism and fortune-telling still have a hold over some older Koreans, but with the rise of Western-style secularism they are losing sway.

I don't think the flag is pagan or even a stumbling block to any Korean Christian. However, I imagine the taegeuk could bother some Western Christians. For that reason it might be better to avoid it.
Click to expand...

A.Joseph said:
Yeah, I mean there are plenty of cultural distinctions worldwide - as long as we don’t build our faith around it and it is not an offense to God.... look at the southerners and the confederate flag... I’m not sure where I’m going with this, lol ..... can I get a Jesus fish?
Click to expand...

This is an interesting thread. It intrigues me when it's so obvious to find a dubious symbol in eastern culture (or a foreign culture), yet our (USA) courthouses, cities, and money are still to this day often adorned with pagan symbols and literal statues/images of gods and goddesses of ancient Greece and Rome but we find it easier to disassociate with our own pagan symbols in some ways, but are so clinical in dissecting another culture's situations. And I'm saying that also as an American who just had to do a double take as I was reading this thread going, "Wait a minute--we do this everywhere, and a lot!" These things have come to bother me more lately. (Perhaps it's too much of that Covenanter sympathizing!) But even the idea that we make an oath over our heart...to...a flag (a symbol)...makes me uncomfortable lately. It has been something I have been struggling with...whether it is lawful or right to pay homage/take an oath to a symbol with a pledge that has dubious (Deistic) undertones.
 
Jo_Was said:
This is an interesting thread. It intrigues me when it's so obvious to find a dubious symbol in eastern culture (or a foreign culture), yet our (USA) courthouses, cities, and money are still to this day often adorned with pagan symbols and literal statues/images of gods and goddesses of ancient Greece and Rome but we find it easier to disassociate with our own pagan symbols in some ways, but are so clinical in dissecting another culture's situations. And I'm saying that also as an American who just had to do a double take as I was reading this thread going, "Wait a minute--we do this everywhere, and a lot!" These things have come to bother me more lately. (Perhaps it's too much of that Covenanter sympathizing!) But even the idea that we make an oath over our heart...to...a flag (a symbol)...makes me uncomfortable lately. It has been something I have been struggling with...whether it is lawful or right to pay homage/take an oath to a symbol with a pledge that has dubious (Deistic) undertones.
Click to expand...

And to make matters worse, the city of Washington DC is one whole occultic grid.
 
Jo_Was said:
This is an interesting thread. It intrigues me when it's so obvious to find a dubious symbol in eastern culture (or a foreign culture), yet our (USA) courthouses, cities, and money are still to this day often adorned with pagan symbols and literal statues/images of gods and goddesses of ancient Greece and Rome but we find it easier to disassociate with our own pagan symbols in some ways, but are so clinical in dissecting another culture's situations. And I'm saying that also as an American who just had to do a double take as I was reading this thread going, "Wait a minute--we do this everywhere, and a lot!" These things have come to bother me more lately. (Perhaps it's too much of that Covenanter sympathizing!) But even the idea that we make an oath over our heart...to...a flag (a symbol)...makes me uncomfortable lately. It has been something I have been struggling with...whether it is lawful or right to pay homage/take an oath to a symbol with a pledge that has dubious (Deistic) undertones.
Click to expand...
Interesting points, just this evening, prior to putting a few dollars in the collection plate, I took a glance at the symbolic figures on our dollar bill, thinking to myself, man, this is pagan to the core.... I guess if you worship money you are basically bowing to a pagan god regardless
 
Why do the pagans get all the good geometric patterns?

Why call Washington D.C. an "occultic grid" - all math is God's math, right?
 
Jo_Was said:
...[O]ur (USA) courthouses, cities, and money are still to this day often adorned with pagan symbols and literal statues/images of gods and goddesses of ancient Greece and Rome.
Click to expand...

I think it's safe to say that any pagan religious association has been replaced by symbolism. I'd wager that a majority of those who visit the Statue of Liberty aren't there to bow at Lady Liberty's feet. Greco-Roman paganism is dead and has been dead for well over a thousand years. Were our context different, for instance if we were living in the fourth century A.D., then those statues and symbols would be better avoided. For us, a statue of Ganesh would be a problem because worship of Ganesh actually does take place, and that on a large scale. A statue of Mary, too, even if somehow not intended as worship, would for the same reason be a bad idea.

I have no problem litening to Wagner's Ring Cycle not only because it is not intended for worship, but no one would ever even consider it in any sense religious.

Jo_Was said:
But even the idea that we make an oath over our heart...to...a flag (a symbol)...makes me uncomfortable lately. It has been something I have been struggling with...whether it is lawful or right to pay homage/take an oath to a symbol with a pledge that has dubious (Deistic) undertones.
Click to expand...

This Canadian thinks all that holding your hand over your heart looks a bit dumb.

For my part, I won't even sing the Canadian anthem anymore. Silly song anyway.

Jo_Was said:
(Perhaps it's too much of that Covenanter sympathizing!)
Click to expand...

Is that a bad thing? :)
 
Don't forget days of the week. Up to this point, I've yet to meet the Puritan who refuses to use their pagan names. Is one lurking about here? ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

P
  • Locked
Great Church Sign
2
Replies
45
Views
5K
Paul Nowlan
P
Romans922
  • Locked
Church Fathers on the Sign of the Cross
Replies
17
Views
6K
tcalbrecht
tcalbrecht
Backwoods Presbyterian
  • Locked
Yet Another Bad Church Sign
Replies
14
Views
4K
Bengibor
B
Parakaleo
  • Locked
United Pentecostal Church Sign Gets Confrontational
Replies
17
Views
5K
KMK
KMK
cupotea
  • Locked
What is the
Replies
17
Views
3K
regswrb
regswrb
Back
Top