Results 1 to 18 of 18

Thread: Most Overrated/Underrated NBA players of all time

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Posts
    2,662
    Blog Entries
    1

    Most Overrated/Underrated NBA players of all time

    I opened a lil' hornets nest in the Iverson thread by saying that he's the most overrated NBA player of all time. My one disclaimer is that I didn't watch basketball before the 80's so I'm hardly qualified to speak for previous eras.

    But I would love to hear the lists of others. Please share your personal TOP 5 overrated and TOP 5 underrated.

    I will gladly jump in the mix later but I've got to run to prayer meeting now...

  2. #2
    Tough question. Ill state some overrated and underrated players playing now.

    Underated

    1.Manu Ginobili- His numbers have dropped a bit due to injury. He isnt even a starter. But everyone knows that he is a great player. His scoring ability is up there. I hope he leaves the spurs and goes to a team where he shines.
    2.Kevin Durant- Only been in the league for 4 years and he is already an all star. His game still hasnt developed but he is a natural born shooter. He is overshadowed by all the greats today.
    3.Chris Bosh- only 25 years old. He is beginning to develop. Good rebouder and good scorer.
    4.Carmelo Anthony- Carmelo is amazing. He not only has the body to over power defenders but he is a shooter!
    5. Kobe Bryant- Yes, Kobe Bryant. Kobe receives ALOT of hate from people. He is highly unappreciated by a vast majority of people who follow the Nba.

    Overated

    1. Lebron James- When people are comparing you to Michael Jordan and calling you the best of all time and its only your 7th year in the league, you know your overated. Lebron is 6'8, 260 pounds, and playing small foward. His athleticism is incredible, dont get me wrong. His dunks? AMAZING. But he is not a great shooter and is horrible at free throws. Calling him "king" is crazy. King of what?
    But of course he adds to this. His tatoo on his back reading " Chosen One" helps to add to the cult surrounding him. As well as his " we are witnesses" commercials.

    Ill think of some more later..
    "I thank Thee that many of my prayers have been refused. I have asked amiss and do not have, I have prayed from lusts and been rejected, I have longed for Egypt and been given a wilderness".-Valley of Vision ( collection of Purtan prayers)

    Julio, Amaya
    Clifton, NewJersey
    Reformed Baptist Church of North Bergen
    Follow our blog: http://reformed-forhisglory.blogspot.com/

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Dec 2002
    Posts
    2,305
    Underrated:

    * John Stockton - in the hall of legends, he get lost amongst Isaiah, Magic, Jordan, and Bird. For a pure PG, he's my first pick of all time, if I'm building a team and not an All-Star list.


    Overrated:

    * Shaq - I would rather listen to his CD Shaq Diesel, while playing Shaq-Fu, and watching Kazaam! than ever see him on the court again. Is that an overstatement?

    In general - solid (even perfect) role players, and low-key leaders are always underrated, and the physical specimens are always overrated.
    Jeremy
    SBC
    NC

    "No heart can conceive that treasury of mercies which lies in this one privilege, in having liberty and ability to approach unto God at all times, according to his mind and will." - John Owen

  4. #4
    Shaq - I would rather listen to his CD Shaq Diesel, while playing Shaq-Fu, and watching Kazaam! than ever see him on the court again. Is that an overstatement?
    Whoa. Shaq, overrated? I disagree. Look at his field goal percentage. Just awesome.
    "I thank Thee that many of my prayers have been refused. I have asked amiss and do not have, I have prayed from lusts and been rejected, I have longed for Egypt and been given a wilderness".-Valley of Vision ( collection of Purtan prayers)

    Julio, Amaya
    Clifton, NewJersey
    Reformed Baptist Church of North Bergen
    Follow our blog: http://reformed-forhisglory.blogspot.com/

  5. #5
    Christian Laettner - what on earth was he doing on the Dream Team??? And his stint in the NBA... come on.
    Ben
    Chaplain, US Army
    Stuttgart, Germany
    TE Potomac Presbytery, PCA
    www.thebenaddiction.com

    "Whenever I'm about to do something, I think, 'would an idiot do that?' And if they would, I do not do that thing." -- Dwight Schrute

    "I've been so thoroughly trained that I don't even need to think before I speak." -- Harry Crumb

  6. Quote Originally Posted by SolaScriptura View Post
    Christian Laettner - what on earth was he doing on the Dream Team??? And his stint in the NBA... come on.
    Got that right, Ben.
    [FONT=Book Antiqua][SIZE=2][COLOR=black]Ivan Schoen ~ [/COLOR][/SIZE][/FONT][FONT=Book Antiqua][SIZE=2][COLOR=black]The Church in [/COLOR][/SIZE][/FONT][FONT=Book Antiqua][SIZE=2][COLOR=black]Poplar Grove, IL[/COLOR][/SIZE][/FONT]
    [SIZE=2][FONT=Book Antiqua][COLOR=black]=================================[/COLOR][/FONT][/SIZE]
    [LEFT][SIZE=2][FONT=Book Antiqua][COLOR=black][SIZE=2][FONT=Book Antiqua][COLOR=black]"As a single footstep will not make a path on the earth, so a single thought will not make a pathway in the mind. To make a deep physical path, we walk again and again. To make a deep mental path, we must think over and over the kind of thoughts we wish to dominate our lives." ~ Henry David Thoreau[/COLOR][/FONT][/SIZE][/COLOR][/FONT][/SIZE][SIZE=2][FONT=Book Antiqua][COLOR=black][/LEFT]
    [/COLOR][/FONT][/SIZE]

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Posts
    2,662
    Blog Entries
    1
    Overrated:

    1. Allen Iverson, for reasons given in the other thread
    2. Charles Barkley, bark is/was much bigger than his bite
    3. Reggie Miller, a one trick pony
    4. Vince Carter, famous for dunks, just not a clutch player
    5. Tracy McGrady, you can only blame the rest of his teams for so long in not ever winning a single playoff series

    Special Honorable Mention: Rick Fox, I'd have him overrated in the WNBA. Seriously.

    Underrated:

    1. Adrian Dantley, not a household name and yet he scored 30+ four consecutive years and I think 2 scoring titles (?)
    2. Mitch Richmond, great defense with sniper accuracy on offense
    3. Chris Mullin, sweet shooter and just solid all around but always on miserable teams
    4. Scottie Pippen, incredible defensive player who really fed Jordan's career
    5. Hakeem Olajuwon, I only put him here because he very well may have been the greatest center ever but no one seems to give him that credit.

    Other [very] random favs: Shawn Kemp [young], Eddie Jones, Kenny Anderson, Dennis Scott, Robert "Tractor" Traylor, Kerry Kittles, Shandon Anderson, Vinny Johnson, Tom Gugliotta, Terry Porter, Steve Smith, and Robert Horry--only cause if he was on your team you could pretty much get that ring sized up!

  8. #8
    Quote Originally Posted by awretchsavedbygrace View Post
    Tough question. Ill state some overrated and underrated players playing now.

    Underated


    5. Kobe Bryant- Yes, Kobe Bryant. Kobe receives ALOT of hate from people. He is highly unappreciated by a vast majority of people who follow the Nba.

    Not Kobe
    Claudiu
    Reformation Community Church
    Spokane, WA
    "Ultimately all things are disciplined by theology."

  9. #9
    Underrated:

    Horace Grant, John Paxson...oh wait...this is for all NBA teams...I'm a bulls fan...

    1. Scottie Pippen (who should go to the hall this year)
    2. Clyde Drexler
    3. John Stockton
    4. B.J. Armstrong...just kidding

    Overrated:

    1. Shaq (FG ptc is so high because he just stands under the basket, pushes everyone out of the way and dunks, let's look at FT ptc...)
    2. Kobe
    3. Barkley
    4. Karl Malone


    I should clarify that after Jordan retired, there was no real reason for me to watch NBA basketball anymore. It has become a waste of time. Rarely do you see anyone play any defense, and everyone seems to be in it only for the money and not the game.
    Elder Andrew Barnes (PCA)
    Christ Presbyterian Church (Kansas City, MO)
    Sermon Audio
    Twitter

  10. #10
    Quote Originally Posted by Romans922 View Post
    Underrated:

    3. John Stockton

    Overrated:

    4. Karl Malone
    Andrew,

    This makes no sense. Without Malone, Stockton plays a couple of years in the NBA and is never heard from again. That could be the greatest 1-2 combo ever.
    Fred Greco
    Senior Pastor, Christ Church PCA (Katy, TX)
    Christ Church Blog

    "The heart is the main thing in true religion...It is the hinge and turning-point in the condition of man's soul. If the heart is alive to God and quickened by the Spirit, the man is a living Christian. If the heart is dead and has not the Spirit, the man is dead before God." (J.C. Ryle)

  11. #11
    You got me, I just couldn't stand Malone when they were playing the Bulls for the championship. I always love guys who make assists (Nash, Pistol Pete, Stockton)...
    Elder Andrew Barnes (PCA)
    Christ Presbyterian Church (Kansas City, MO)
    Sermon Audio
    Twitter

  12. #12
    I agree with Clyde the Glide being underrated. He would have won championships with the Blazers if not for Jabar/Johnson/Worthy.

    I also think Joe Dumars was underrated simply because of the personalities of Thomas, Rodman, Lambier, and Salley. Who can compete with them for attention?


    Village Church of Rosena Ranch

    Transformation Ministries

    "Preparing a sermon is like cooking a meal. You need pots and pans and utensils, but you don't bring them out to the table where people are eating." Derek Thomas


    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Suggestions?

  13. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by smhbbag View Post
    Overrated:
    * Shaq - I would rather listen to his CD Shaq Diesel, while playing Shaq-Fu, and watching Kazaam! than ever see him on the court again. Is that an overstatement?
    I don't know enough about basketball to weigh-in, but I do know if one were to be doing the above three things mentioned, he would be having a great time! Shaq the basketball player is so-so, but Shaq the personality goes hard!

    Andrew Silva
    Ruling Elder, Dallas Reformed Presbyterian Church (RPCNA), Flower Mound,TX
    Dallas RPC Facebook page
    North DFW area

    My blog - Lose Your Life
    Follow me - Twitter

    He is your friend who pushes you nearer to God. - Abraham Kuyper

  14. #14
    Quote Originally Posted by fredtgreco View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by Romans922 View Post
    Underrated:

    3. John Stockton

    Overrated:

    4. Karl Malone
    Andrew,

    This makes no sense. Without Malone, Stockton plays a couple of years in the NBA and is never heard from again. That could be the greatest 1-2 combo ever.
    Can you be the greatest of all time but never actually in a single year? They never won. Plus Malone wore LA Gear!
    Jon Peters
    Member, Reformation Fellowship (OPC) (Roseville, CA)
    Folsom, CA

  15. #15
    Quote Originally Posted by Michael Turner View Post
    Overrated:

    1. Allen Iverson, for reasons given in the other thread
    2. Charles Barkley, bark is/was much bigger than his bite
    3. Reggie Miller, a one trick pony
    4. Vince Carter, famous for dunks, just not a clutch player
    5. Tracy McGrady, you can only blame the rest of his teams for so long in not ever winning a single playoff series

    Special Honorable Mention: Rick Fox, I'd have him overrated in the WNBA. Seriously.

    Underrated:

    1. Adrian Dantley, not a household name and yet he scored 30+ four consecutive years and I think 2 scoring titles (?)
    2. Mitch Richmond, great defense with sniper accuracy on offense
    3. Chris Mullin, sweet shooter and just solid all around but always on miserable teams
    4. Scottie Pippen, incredible defensive player who really fed Jordan's career
    5. Hakeem Olajuwon, I only put him here because he very well may have been the greatest center ever but no one seems to give him that credit.

    Other [very] random favs: Shawn Kemp [young], Eddie Jones, Kenny Anderson, Dennis Scott, Robert "Tractor" Traylor, Kerry Kittles, Shandon Anderson, Vinny Johnson, Tom Gugliotta, Terry Porter, Steve Smith, and Robert Horry--only cause if he was on your team you could pretty much get that ring sized up!
    Your killing me. Vince Carter is arguably the best dunker of all time. Reggie Miller is arguably one of the most clutch shooters in all of nba history, certainly one of the best and also one of the best 3 point shooters ever.

    ---------- Post added at 06:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:23 PM ----------

    I should clarify that after Jordan retired, there was no real reason for me to watch NBA basketball anymore. It has become a waste of time. Rarely do you see anyone play any defense, and everyone seems to be in it only for the money and not the game.
    Maybe your not a nba fan, just a Jordan fan. There are alot of players who play defense. Look at Josh Smith from the Atlanta Hawks. He is the youngest player to reach 1000 blocks.

    ---------- Post added at 06:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:29 PM ----------

    Shaq (FG ptc is so high because he just stands under the basket, pushes everyone out of the way and dunks, let's look at FT ptc...)
    Negative. Shaq has post moves.

    Some big guys just cant shoot FT's. Sorry, but the whole "he pushes everyone" is not a good argument. If you have a big body, you should use that to your advantage.Charging is a violation and its the Ref's job to call it, not Shaqs.
    "I thank Thee that many of my prayers have been refused. I have asked amiss and do not have, I have prayed from lusts and been rejected, I have longed for Egypt and been given a wilderness".-Valley of Vision ( collection of Purtan prayers)

    Julio, Amaya
    Clifton, NewJersey
    Reformed Baptist Church of North Bergen
    Follow our blog: http://reformed-forhisglory.blogspot.com/

  16. #16
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Posts
    2,662
    Blog Entries
    1
    Quote Originally Posted by awretchsavedbygrace View Post
    Your killing me. Vince Carter is arguably the best dunker of all time. Reggie Miller is arguably one of the most clutch shooters in all of nba history, certainly one of the best and also one of the best 3 point shooters ever.
    No argument on either of those points but it doesn't change the overrated factor, it strengthens it. How many Vinsanity dunks ever amounted to a win? Reggie was an incredible 3-point shooter but was a pylon on defense and I'm not sure if I can remember him ever driving the ball to the hoop. Like I said, one trick ponies--both of them. Doesn't mean they are bad, just overrated. That's all.

  17. #17
    Quote Originally Posted by awretchsavedbygrace View Post
    I should clarify that after Jordan retired, there was no real reason for me to watch NBA basketball anymore. It has become a waste of time. Rarely do you see anyone play any defense, and everyone seems to be in it only for the money and not the game.
    Maybe your not a nba fan, just a Jordan fan. There are alot of players who play defense. Look at Josh Smith from the Atlanta Hawks. He is the youngest player to reach 1000 blocks.
    No, I thought that the NBA was actually good before Jordan (see Johnson, Bird, Doc, Wilt....)
    Elder Andrew Barnes (PCA)
    Christ Presbyterian Church (Kansas City, MO)
    Sermon Audio
    Twitter

  18. #18
    Join Date
    Dec 2002
    Posts
    2,305
    Some big guys just cant shoot FT's. Sorry, but the whole "he pushes everyone" is not a good argument.
    This is the one area I don't give Shaq any grief. I recall reading that he broke his right wrist pretty badly after falling out of a tree as a kid. Evidently, it healed awkwardly and doesn't allow him to bend it backwards. Without that, there's nothing to do except pretend it's a shot-put.
    Jeremy
    SBC
    NC

    "No heart can conceive that treasury of mercies which lies in this one privilege, in having liberty and ability to approach unto God at all times, according to his mind and will." - John Owen

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
About us
The PuritanBoard exists to promote robust discussion of theology in a Confessionally Reformed context. The modern trend of short statements of faith belies the many places where the Scriptures teach with great clarity. Though our respective Reformed confessions sometimes disagree, we believe that Churches have been given the gifts of teachers and elders to lead to the unity of the faith and the result of that unity is a Confessional Church confessing together: "This is what the Scriptures teach." The Confessions are secondary to the authority of Scripture itself but they arise out of Scripture as a standard exposition of the Word of God.