Closed Thread
Results 1 to 24 of 24

Thread: Bar Tunes and Hymnody

  1. #1
    PuritanCovenanter's Avatar
    PuritanCovenanter is offline. Norseman Moderator
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Speedway, Indiana
    Posts
    11,639
    Blog Entries
    36
    Thanks
    1,975
    Thanked 2,280 Times in 1,235 Posts

    Bar Tunes and Hymnody

    I was recently told this...

    It is my understanding that the term bar music that was used in his (Luther's and Calvin's) day did not refer to drinking bars, but was a technical term for a use of a certain structure of music containing a pattern of bars of music. Modern writings take the term completely out of context.

    I always had heard the story as drinking bars and only recently heard what I think is the real history. I heard it from a professional hymn and song writer who is Lutheran, so I'm going to give him deference until I have time to research it further.
    ...in connection to a discussion I entered into concerning music and Hymnody. I always understood that some Hymns were put to musical arrangement that came from drinking bar songs. This was presented to me today as the possible truth to understanding that this might not be true.

    What thinkest thou? I really haven't studied this topic at all. Does anyone here have any insight on this issue?

    Norseman Moderator

    R. Martin Snyder

    1689er
    http://www.puritanboard.com/blogs/puritancovenanter/

    "Our object should not be to have scripture on our side but to be on the side of scripture; and however dear any sentiment may have become by being long entertained, so soon as it is seen to be contrary to the Bible, we must be prepared to abandon it without hesitation."
    William Symington
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  2. The Following User Says Thank You to PuritanCovenanter For This Useful Post:

    Rich Koster (07-24-2009)

  3. #2
    toddpedlar's Avatar
    toddpedlar is offline. Iron Dramatist
    Join Date
    Jul 2004
    Location
    Decorah, IA
    Posts
    6,672
    Thanks
    263
    Thanked 2,636 Times in 1,358 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by PuritanCovenanter View Post
    I was recently told this...

    It is my understanding that the term bar music that was used in his (Luther's and Calvin's) day did not refer to drinking bars, but was a technical term for a use of a certain structure of music containing a pattern of bars of music. Modern writings take the term completely out of context.

    I always had heard the story as drinking bars and only recently heard what I think is the real history. I heard it from a professional hymn and song writer who is Lutheran, so I'm going to give him deference until I have time to research it further.
    ...in connection to a discussion I entered into concerning music and Hymnody. I always understood that some Hymns were put to musical arrangement that came from drinking bar songs. This was presented to me today as the possible truth to understanding that this might not be true.

    What thinkest thou? I really haven't studied this topic at all. Does anyone here have any insight on this issue?
    "bar form" tunes mean those that have a fixed meter... e.g. common meter, in which all the Scottish Psalter tunes are written. This is as opposed to "free form" tunes that characterize other forms of music in which there is not a repeated syllabification.

    So "bar tunes" is correct - as long as you know what is meant by the term. It is NOT honky tonk music, as some claim.
    Todd K. Pedlar
    member, First Congregational Church, (CCCC) Cresco, IA
    My Blog: In Principio Deus
    Podcast I co-host: Covenant Radio
    Streaming Audio by the Co-hosts of Covenant Radio

    "As God did not at first choose you because you were high, He will not now forsake you because you are low."
    John Flavel in Keeping the Heart

    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Joining PB's Politics & Government Forum
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  4. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to toddpedlar For This Useful Post:

    KMK (07-24-2009), PuritanCovenanter (07-23-2009), Rangerus (07-26-2009), Rich Koster (07-24-2009)

  5. #3
    gene_mingo's Avatar
    gene_mingo is offline. Puritanboard Junior
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Cottonwood, AZ
    Posts
    1,607
    Thanks
    1,023
    Thanked 165 Times in 132 Posts
    I know not about hymns, but the star spangled banner got its music from "to anacreon in heaven" which is an old beer drinking song.
    Josh Taylor
    Verde Valley Reformed Chapel, OPC
    Cottonwood, AZ
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  6. The Following User Says Thank You to gene_mingo For This Useful Post:

    PuritanCovenanter (07-23-2009)

  7. #4
    PuritanCovenanter's Avatar
    PuritanCovenanter is offline. Norseman Moderator
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Speedway, Indiana
    Posts
    11,639
    Blog Entries
    36
    Thanks
    1,975
    Thanked 2,280 Times in 1,235 Posts
    I did a google search on Luther and bar tunes. This seemed to be a well documented source. Mark Gibson's blog is even mentioned which surprised me since the site looks like a KJV only kinda site.

    Didn’t Martin Luther use drinking and bar tunes in his music?

    Norseman Moderator

    R. Martin Snyder

    1689er
    http://www.puritanboard.com/blogs/puritancovenanter/

    "Our object should not be to have scripture on our side but to be on the side of scripture; and however dear any sentiment may have become by being long entertained, so soon as it is seen to be contrary to the Bible, we must be prepared to abandon it without hesitation."
    William Symington
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  8. The Following User Says Thank You to PuritanCovenanter For This Useful Post:

    Rich Koster (07-24-2009)

  9. #5
    greenbaggins's Avatar
    greenbaggins is offline. Administrator
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Hague, North Dakota
    Posts
    3,198
    Thanks
    1,006
    Thanked 2,612 Times in 895 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by PuritanCovenanter View Post
    I did a google search on Luther and bar tunes. This seemed to be a well documented source. Mark Gibson's blog is even mentioned which surprised me since the site looks like a KJV only kinda site.

    Didn’t Martin Luther use drinking and bar tunes in his music?
    The link is entirely accurate. Bar form refers to AABA form. Luther wrote most of the tunes himself to his own hymns, although a few were adapted from other church music sources, and only one was taken (not from a drinking song), but from a folk tune. CCM's claim on Luther as favoring drinking songs should by now be exposed for the wicked falsehood it is. They will riposte with this infamous rejoinder of Luther's "Why should the devil have all the best music?" But in context, Luther was not talking about taking bar music for his own, but the devil in this quotation was the Roman Catholic Church, and Luther was arguing for great new tunes composed for the Lutheran church. Luther once said, "a pastor who doesn't know anything about music is useless to me."
    Rev. Lane Keister
    Teaching Elder, PCA, North Dakota (working out of bounds in a CRC and an RCA church)
    http://greenbaggins.wordpress.com
    http://brahmsgreenglove.blogspot.com
    http://accenttranslation.blogspot.com
    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Suggestions?
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  10. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to greenbaggins For This Useful Post:

    Classical Presbyterian (07-27-2009), Marrow Man (07-25-2009), PuritanCovenanter (07-24-2009), Rich Koster (07-24-2009)

  11. #6
    Jimmy the Greek's Avatar
    Jimmy the Greek is offline. Puritanboard Senior
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    North Texas
    Posts
    2,311
    Thanks
    732
    Thanked 863 Times in 480 Posts
    However, many 19th century Hymns used melodies/tunes from secular music of the day. It is my understanding that many of these may have properly been associated with saloon music.
    Jim
    1689 LBCF
    Independent Bible Church
    North Texas, USA
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  12. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to Jimmy the Greek For This Useful Post:

    PuritanCovenanter (07-24-2009), Rich Koster (07-24-2009)

  13. #7
    Rich Koster's Avatar
    Rich Koster is offline now. Puritanboard Senior
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Browns Mills NJ
    Posts
    2,784
    Blog Entries
    3
    Thanks
    713
    Thanked 838 Times in 493 Posts
    The lyrics definitely give glory to God. As bad as I sing, the melody would probably not be detected in many cases. I'm not ready to take an exacto knife to the Trinity hymnal (or any similar) if I found that a melody knock off from a folk song, often sung in a tavern, was used in a hymn. A few of the Psalms have "to the tune of" listed, and most of the hymns were composed before the copyright laws were in place, so no Christian principle is violated here. I'm not going into RPW fine points with this. Glorious Things of Thee are Spoken wasn't ejected for being associated with Nazi Germay's national anthem. They were both based on Hayden's melody.
    Rich Koster
    Browns Mills NJ USA
    Member of Covenant Baptist, Lumberton NJ (1689ers)
    http://cbclumberton.wordpress.com/

    The Often Goofy Reformed Eccentric
    Romans 7:14-25
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  14. The Following User Says Thank You to Rich Koster For This Useful Post:

    PuritanCovenanter (07-24-2009)

  15. #8
    jambo's Avatar
    jambo is offline. Puritanboard Sophomore
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Lisburn, Northern Ireland, UK
    Posts
    939
    Thanks
    216
    Thanked 517 Times in 287 Posts
    Going back further, to the time of the Arian controversey, did not both Arius and Athanasius try to propagate their theology by little ditties using the popular tunes of their day.
    Stuart
    Elder, Lambeg Baptist, Northern Ireland, UK

    In Him the fulness of the Godhead dwells in bodily form and in Him you are complete (Col 2.9-10)

    The Christian is a person who makes it easy for others to believe in God. (RM M'Cheyne)
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  16. #9
    KMK's Avatar
    KMK
    KMK is offline. Rot a Redom
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Wrightwood, CA
    Posts
    9,353
    Blog Entries
    1
    Thanks
    3,848
    Thanked 1,518 Times in 871 Posts
    It is very difficult to compose a melody that is not in some way derivative. Unless you Bach himself you can always be accused of 'stealing'. (And some even try to accuse him) This does not mean that the melody is no 'composed'.

    Besides, even in cases where new words are placed with old melodies, what difference does it make? A melody is a just pattern of pitches. There is nothing moral or immoral about a 'd' following a 'c' following a 'g' etc.


    http://www.villagecommunitychurch.org/


    "Preparing a sermon is like cooking a meal. You need pots and pans and utensils, but you don't bring them out to the table where people are eating." Derek Thomas


    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Suggestions?
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  17. #10
    LawrenceU's Avatar
    LawrenceU is offline. Puritanboard Doctor
    Join Date
    Oct 2002
    Location
    Deep in the heart of Dixie - Mobile, Alabama
    Posts
    6,955
    Thanks
    969
    Thanked 3,355 Times in 1,696 Posts
    Actually, Bach did a bit of 'plagarism' himself. Air on the G String is a take off on Pachelbel's Canon in D Maj.
    We shall not adjust our Bible to the age; but before we have done with it, by God's grace, we shall adjust the age to the Bible. - Charles Haddon Spurgeon

    Lawrence Underwood, Jr.
    Pastor - Providence Family Fellowship / Mobile, Alabama
    1644/46 LBC
    My Blog - Imprimis
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  18. #11
    greenbaggins's Avatar
    greenbaggins is offline. Administrator
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Hague, North Dakota
    Posts
    3,198
    Thanks
    1,006
    Thanked 2,612 Times in 895 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by LawrenceU View Post
    Actually, Bach did a bit of 'plagarism' himself. Air on the G String is a take off on Pachelbel's Canon in D Maj.
    Not really. The chord progression is an extremely common one for the time period. Vivaldi used it approximately six thousand times in his music. The tune isn't remotely similar. For Pachelbel, the tune is tied to the chord. For Bach, it is not. And like I said, the chord progression is as common in Baroque as dirt is.
    Rev. Lane Keister
    Teaching Elder, PCA, North Dakota (working out of bounds in a CRC and an RCA church)
    http://greenbaggins.wordpress.com
    http://brahmsgreenglove.blogspot.com
    http://accenttranslation.blogspot.com
    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Suggestions?
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  19. #12
    VictorBravo's Avatar
    VictorBravo is offline. Administrator
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Tacoma, WA
    Posts
    5,759
    Blog Entries
    1
    Thanks
    202
    Thanked 2,083 Times in 1,097 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by greenbaggins View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by LawrenceU View Post
    Actually, Bach did a bit of 'plagarism' himself. Air on the G String is a take off on Pachelbel's Canon in D Maj.
    Not really. The chord progression is an extremely common one for the time period. Vivaldi used it approximately six thousand times in his music. The tune isn't remotely similar. For Pachelbel, the tune is tied to the chord. For Bach, it is not. And like I said, the chord progression is as common in Baroque as dirt is.
    True enough, but I wonder where he got the theme for the Eb Major fugue for organ (you know, the one that is called the St. Anne's).

    It's fair to say that Bach borrowed from all sorts of sources. Everyone did in those days. It was a way of honoring other composers as well as improving on things. People who knew music could recognize such themes. It seems that the drive for originality led to the drive to mediocrity, methinks.

    When I was in music school studying composition back in the 70s, all the rage was to avoid being "deriviative." Yup, that really worked. John Cage was the hero. . . .
    Raymond Victor Bottomly
    Providence Reformed Baptist Church, Tacoma, WA

    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- How to access Politics and Government forum
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  20. The Following User Says Thank You to VictorBravo For This Useful Post:

    a mere housewife (07-24-2009)

  21. #13
    greenbaggins's Avatar
    greenbaggins is offline. Administrator
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Hague, North Dakota
    Posts
    3,198
    Thanks
    1,006
    Thanked 2,612 Times in 895 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by victorbravo View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by greenbaggins View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by LawrenceU View Post
    Actually, Bach did a bit of 'plagarism' himself. Air on the G String is a take off on Pachelbel's Canon in D Maj.
    Not really. The chord progression is an extremely common one for the time period. Vivaldi used it approximately six thousand times in his music. The tune isn't remotely similar. For Pachelbel, the tune is tied to the chord. For Bach, it is not. And like I said, the chord progression is as common in Baroque as dirt is.
    True enough, but I wonder where he got the theme for the Eb Major fugue for organ (you know, the one that is called the St. Anne's).

    It's fair to say that Bach borrowed from all sorts of sources. Everyone did in those days. It was a way of honoring other composers as well as improving on things. People who knew music could recognize such themes. It seems that the drive for originality led to the drive to mediocrity, methinks.

    When I was in music school studying composition back in the 70s, all the rage was to avoid being "deriviative." Yup, that really worked. John Cage was the hero. . . .
    Of course Bach borrowed, as all the others did too. My point was that Bach did not steal from Pachelbel. If anything, the chord progression was part and parcel of the general musical consciousness, the "oral tradition," if you will.

    Yes, John Cage is so not my hero of composition. Anyone who "composed" "Silence" ought to be shot dead, buried, dug out, resurrected, and shot again.
    Rev. Lane Keister
    Teaching Elder, PCA, North Dakota (working out of bounds in a CRC and an RCA church)
    http://greenbaggins.wordpress.com
    http://brahmsgreenglove.blogspot.com
    http://accenttranslation.blogspot.com
    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Suggestions?
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  22. #14
    KMK's Avatar
    KMK
    KMK is offline. Rot a Redom
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Wrightwood, CA
    Posts
    9,353
    Blog Entries
    1
    Thanks
    3,848
    Thanked 1,518 Times in 871 Posts
    Will the Moderators please moderate themselves and keep this thread on track!

    It appears that Randy has struck a 'chord' with the administration.


    http://www.villagecommunitychurch.org/


    "Preparing a sermon is like cooking a meal. You need pots and pans and utensils, but you don't bring them out to the table where people are eating." Derek Thomas


    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Suggestions?
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  23. #15
    LawrenceU's Avatar
    LawrenceU is offline. Puritanboard Doctor
    Join Date
    Oct 2002
    Location
    Deep in the heart of Dixie - Mobile, Alabama
    Posts
    6,955
    Thanks
    969
    Thanked 3,355 Times in 1,696 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by greenbaggins View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by victorbravo View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by greenbaggins View Post

    Not really. The chord progression is an extremely common one for the time period. Vivaldi used it approximately six thousand times in his music. The tune isn't remotely similar. For Pachelbel, the tune is tied to the chord. For Bach, it is not. And like I said, the chord progression is as common in Baroque as dirt is.
    True enough, but I wonder where he got the theme for the Eb Major fugue for organ (you know, the one that is called the St. Anne's).

    It's fair to say that Bach borrowed from all sorts of sources. Everyone did in those days. It was a way of honoring other composers as well as improving on things. People who knew music could recognize such themes. It seems that the drive for originality led to the drive to mediocrity, methinks.

    When I was in music school studying composition back in the 70s, all the rage was to avoid being "deriviative." Yup, that really worked. John Cage was the hero. . . .
    Of course Bach borrowed, as all the others did too. My point was that Bach did not steal from Pachelbel. If anything, the chord progression was part and parcel of the general musical consciousness, the "oral tradition," if you will.

    Yes, John Cage is so not my hero of composition. Anyone who "composed" "Silence" ought to be shot dead, buried, dug out, resurrected, and shot again.
    There is a reason that I put plagiarized in quotes. I know very well that composers borrowed, good ones still do. And, yes that type of chord progression was common in the period. I read a paper where the thesis was because of Bach's father's connection to Pachelbel that he wrote the Air to honour them both.
    We shall not adjust our Bible to the age; but before we have done with it, by God's grace, we shall adjust the age to the Bible. - Charles Haddon Spurgeon

    Lawrence Underwood, Jr.
    Pastor - Providence Family Fellowship / Mobile, Alabama
    1644/46 LBC
    My Blog - Imprimis
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  24. #16
    DMcFadden's Avatar
    DMcFadden is offline. Meum cerebrum nocet
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    San Gabriel, CA
    Posts
    8,174
    Thanks
    1,898
    Thanked 3,920 Times in 1,924 Posts
    Man, you guys love destroying all of the urban myths!

    I'm still waiting for someone to set the words, "as soon as the coin in the coffer rings, a sinner from purgatory springs" to the tune of "Shine Jesus Shine."

    My knowledge of musicology stops at e-g-b-d-f and f-a-c-e. However, didn't some of the 19th century Gospel music draw on the idioms of Stephen Foster for its inspiration???

    When I was in high school (back when we only had one President from Illinois who was born in a log cabin and rose to become the messiah of the world) they were singing "Amazing Grace" to the tune of "The House of the Rising Sun" (about a house of "ill repute").

    It was my understanding that the medieval church was rather non-participatory and that Calvin helped stimulate the singing of the laity by his insistence that good singing was part of worship and the birthright of the whole congregation. His introduction of the Psalter into common usage was a great stride forward.

    Lane, you have better training than any of us. What do you make of the issue of popular tunes and Christian worship?
    Dennis E. McFadden, Ex Mainline Baptist (in Remission)
    Atherton Baptist Homes, CEO
    First Baptist Church of Alhambra, Member, Transformation Ministries (CA)

    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Suggestions?
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  25. #17
    Rich Koster's Avatar
    Rich Koster is offline now. Puritanboard Senior
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Browns Mills NJ
    Posts
    2,784
    Blog Entries
    3
    Thanks
    713
    Thanked 838 Times in 493 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by DMcFadden View Post
    Man, you guys love destroying all of the urban myths!

    I'm still waiting for someone to set the words, "as soon as the coin in the coffer rings, a sinner from purgatory springs" to the tune of "Shine Jesus Shine."

    My knowledge of musicology stops at e-g-b-d-f and f-a-c-e. However, didn't some of the 19th century Gospel music draw on the idioms of Stephen Foster for its inspiration???

    When I was in high school (back when we only had one President from Illinois who was born in a log cabin and rose to become the messiah of the world) they were singing "Amazing Grace" to the tune of "The House of the Rising Sun" (about a house of "ill repute").

    It was my understanding that the medieval church was rather non-participatory and that Calvin helped stimulate the singing of the laity by his insistence that good singing was part of worship and the birthright of the whole congregation. His introduction of the Psalter into common usage was a great stride forward.

    Lane, you have better training than any of us. What do you make of the issue of popular tunes and Christian worship?
    Rich Koster
    Browns Mills NJ USA
    Member of Covenant Baptist, Lumberton NJ (1689ers)
    http://cbclumberton.wordpress.com/

    The Often Goofy Reformed Eccentric
    Romans 7:14-25
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  26. #18
    Skyler's Avatar
    Skyler is offline. Puritanboard Senior
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Ohio
    Posts
    2,231
    Thanks
    338
    Thanked 525 Times in 364 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by greenbaggins View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by PuritanCovenanter View Post
    I did a google search on Luther and bar tunes. This seemed to be a well documented source. Mark Gibson's blog is even mentioned which surprised me since the site looks like a KJV only kinda site.

    Didn’t Martin Luther use drinking and bar tunes in his music?
    The link is entirely accurate. Bar form refers to AABA form. Luther wrote most of the tunes himself to his own hymns, although a few were adapted from other church music sources, and only one was taken (not from a drinking song), but from a folk tune. CCM's claim on Luther as favoring drinking songs should by now be exposed for the wicked falsehood it is. They will riposte with this infamous rejoinder of Luther's "Why should the devil have all the best music?" But in context, Luther was not talking about taking bar music for his own, but the devil in this quotation was the Roman Catholic Church, and Luther was arguing for great new tunes composed for the Lutheran church. Luther once said, "a pastor who doesn't know anything about music is useless to me."
    I heard that quote--"Why should the devil have all the best music?"--in the context of Charles Wesley borrowing drinking songs... hmm...

    A Google search reveals that William Booth also said that, as well as Charles Wesley--curiously enough, both are cited as the first to say that.

    Quote Originally Posted by http://www.jameswatkins.com/churchmusic.htm
    Charles Wesley, who was the song leader for the John Wesley Evangelistic Association during the late 1700's, took English pub tunes and added Christian lyrics, many paraphrased from the Church of England's Prayer Book. Did you know you can sing "One Hundred Bottles of Beer on the Wall" to the tune of "O, For A Thousand Tongues to Sing"? Just a coincidence? I don't think so.
    edit: You gotta admit, it makes it easier to teach new converts the songs... lol!
    Jonathan, A.A.S.
    Audio Engineer
    Reformed Baptist
    Ohio
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  27. #19
    Grillsy's Avatar
    Grillsy is offline. Puritanboard Junior
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Grayson, Kentucky
    Posts
    1,331
    Thanks
    735
    Thanked 229 Times in 134 Posts
    The Charles Wesley quote is untrue.
    Think about it, he was a Methodist lol, back when that meant something.
    But it has been documented that the quote is misattributed.
    Luther did not use secular music, except for at least one tune. He changed it to on original melody after the fact. Then upon Luther's death the melody was changed by to the secular one. Sorry for the lack of footnotes.
    Willie Grills
    Trinity Presbyterian Church
    OPC
    Huntington, WV
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  28. #20
    PuritanCovenanter's Avatar
    PuritanCovenanter is offline. Norseman Moderator
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Speedway, Indiana
    Posts
    11,639
    Blog Entries
    36
    Thanks
    1,975
    Thanked 2,280 Times in 1,235 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by DMcFadden View Post
    When I was in high school... they were singing "Amazing Grace" to the tune of "The House of the Rising Sun" (about a house of "ill repute").
    I had never heard that done until about a year ago. And it was during a Sunday Worship service. I was not impressed.

    Norseman Moderator

    R. Martin Snyder

    1689er
    http://www.puritanboard.com/blogs/puritancovenanter/

    "Our object should not be to have scripture on our side but to be on the side of scripture; and however dear any sentiment may have become by being long entertained, so soon as it is seen to be contrary to the Bible, we must be prepared to abandon it without hesitation."
    William Symington
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  29. #21
    jambo's Avatar
    jambo is offline. Puritanboard Sophomore
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Lisburn, Northern Ireland, UK
    Posts
    939
    Thanks
    216
    Thanked 517 Times in 287 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by PuritanCovenanter View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by DMcFadden View Post
    When I was in high school... they were singing "Amazing Grace" to the tune of "The House of the Rising Sun" (about a house of "ill repute").
    I had never heard that done until about a year ago. And it was during a Sunday Worship service. I was not impressed.
    I have never heard 'Amaziing Grace' sung to 'the House of the Rising Sun' but have sung 'When I Survey the Wondrous Cross' to this tune.

    Tunes work both ways. We often sing 'Thine be the Glory' yet this tune was written to celebrate someone who would now be classed as a war criminal and in a recent BBC poll was named one of the 10 worst Britons of the whole millenium. That is the Duke of Cumberland, otherwise known as 'the butcher' due to his treatment of the clansmen after their defeat at Culloden.

    Its not the tune but the words that count. Indeed there is something symbolic in using a tune that once had non-Christian or even un-Christian lyrics and using the same tune to sing praise to God. That is what the Lord does with people, he changes their song.

    'He put a new song in my mouth, a song of praise to our God' (Ps 40.3)
    Stuart
    Elder, Lambeg Baptist, Northern Ireland, UK

    In Him the fulness of the Godhead dwells in bodily form and in Him you are complete (Col 2.9-10)

    The Christian is a person who makes it easy for others to believe in God. (RM M'Cheyne)
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  30. #22
    greenbaggins's Avatar
    greenbaggins is offline. Administrator
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Hague, North Dakota
    Posts
    3,198
    Thanks
    1,006
    Thanked 2,612 Times in 895 Posts
    Here my deal with Contemporary Christian Music. It's just like Voltaire said about the Holy Roman Empire: it is neither holy, nor Roman, nor an empire. The same is true of CCM: it is neither contemporary (all 70's music), nor Christian (in most cases; there are a few Scripture songs in CCM), nor music.

    This last I will stake myself on, for this reason: music is structured according to phrases. In fact, the parallel of music to language is rather intense: notes=letters, chords=words, phrases=clauses, periods of music=sentences, sections=paragraphs, you get the picture. The beauty of a musical phrase is in an arch shape. It has a rising action, a point of some sort of height (whether dynamically, or pitch, or rhythmic, or chordal, some point of highest tension), and a resolution, which is usually much shorter than the buildup. These phrases, or musical sentences, are then concatenated together to form a far larger arch shape that extends the entire length of the piece or song or hymn.

    Unfortunately, most CCM does not have anything close to this kind of structure. Instead, the structure is very much a moment by moment tension and release, more like jazz. The phrases have zero arch, and much in the way of repeated notes (many hymns do this, too, especially in the revivalist hymn tradition, which was never meant to be kept for posterity!). And it all looks the same, with the very same chord structure for practically every song. Furthermore, it is not conducive to congregational singing. Congregations cannot do that kind of syncopation very well. It winds up being a solo sung (usually poorly!) by the song leader up in the front, wailing away on his guitar with no one else participating. They don't usually give the music to the people, only the words, so the congregation cannot learn the music. I have almost never seen CCM even performed well (and I use the word "performance" on purpose). It's a performance, not worship, and it's usually done poorly.

    Now, there are rare exceptions within the CCM movement, and there are also plenty of bad hymns. I have found the best traditions of hymnody to be the English Anglican tradition, the German Lutheran tradition, the Genevan Psalter, the Scottish Psalter, and the earlier American hymns. These traditions were usually written by folks who knew what music was. They were actual composers. I have little love for the revivalist tradition (where the theology is often bad, also!) or CCM. It has gotten to the point where, if they will not provide me the music, I refuse to sing.

    There are several modern hymn writers doing good things. I think of Paul Jones at Tenth Presbyterian Church, who has written (Boice wrote the words) Hymn for a Modern Reformation, an excellent compilation of about 15 hymns (I was in the choir at the time they recorded the hymns for a CD), based on the 5 solas, and the 5 points of Calvinism. Also, I think that Getty's hymn "In Christ Alone" is a good modern example of a hymn that has the proper musical structure (not to mention great words).
    Rev. Lane Keister
    Teaching Elder, PCA, North Dakota (working out of bounds in a CRC and an RCA church)
    http://greenbaggins.wordpress.com
    http://brahmsgreenglove.blogspot.com
    http://accenttranslation.blogspot.com
    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Suggestions?
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  31. The Following User Says Thank You to greenbaggins For This Useful Post:

    PuritanCovenanter (07-27-2009)

  32. #23
    a mere housewife's Avatar
    a mere housewife is offline. Hench Wench
    Join Date
    Apr 2003
    Location
    Indianapolis, IN
    Posts
    5,103
    Thanks
    1,985
    Thanked 2,029 Times in 1,012 Posts
    . . . music is structured according to phrases. In fact, the parallel of music to language is rather intense: notes=letters, chords=words, phrases=clauses, periods of music=sentences, sections=paragraphs, you get the picture. The beauty of a musical phrase is in an arch shape. It has a rising action, a point of some sort of height (whether dynamically, or pitch, or rhythmic, or chordal, some point of highest tension), and a resolution, which is usually much shorter than the buildup. These phrases, or musical sentences, are then concatenated together to form a far larger arch shape that extends the entire length of the piece or song or hymn.

    Unfortunately, most CCM does not have anything close to this kind of structure. Instead, the structure is very much a moment by moment tension and release, more like jazz. The phrases have zero arch, and much in the way of repeated notes (many hymns do this, too, especially in the revivalist hymn tradition, which was never meant to be kept for posterity!). And it all looks the same, with the very same chord structure for practically every song.
    Thanks for this.
    Heidi Zartman
    Indianapolis, IN

    Whom have I in heaven but thee? and there is none upon earth that I desire beside thee.
    My flesh and my heart faileth: but God is the strength of my heart, and my portion for ever.

    An anni babtist is a thing I am not a member of; I am a Pisplikan just now & a Prisbeteren at Kercaldy my native town which though dirty is clein in the country . . . (Marjorie Fleming)
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

  33. #24
    PuritanCovenanter's Avatar
    PuritanCovenanter is offline. Norseman Moderator
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Speedway, Indiana
    Posts
    11,639
    Blog Entries
    36
    Thanks
    1,975
    Thanked 2,280 Times in 1,235 Posts
    I agree with Lane.

    Norseman Moderator

    R. Martin Snyder

    1689er
    http://www.puritanboard.com/blogs/puritancovenanter/

    "Our object should not be to have scripture on our side but to be on the side of scripture; and however dear any sentiment may have become by being long entertained, so soon as it is seen to be contrary to the Bible, we must be prepared to abandon it without hesitation."
    William Symington
    Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!

Closed Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69