Results 1 to 20 of 20

A capella Exclusive Psalmody discuss Objections to Singing of Psalms in Worship in the Worship forums; I am currently writing a lengthy paper on the topic of "Music in the Worship of God" for my session to review and consider and ...

  1. #1
    re4med's Avatar
    re4med is offline. Puritanboard Freshman
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    337

    Objections to Singing of Psalms in Worship

    I am currently writing a lengthy paper on the topic of "Music in the Worship of God" for my session to review and consider and will have a section on the leading objections to "Psalms in Worship". I have a few of them but would like the input of my more studied brothers and sisters on this topic.

    What objections have you encountered?

    This is not meant to be a debate on the topic (as we have the elsewhere on this board). I am simply seeking information.

    Thanks!
    William F. Hill, Jr.
    Calvary Presbyterian Church, (PCA)
    Student at Greenville Presbyterian Theological Seminary
    Under care of Calvary Presbytery (PCA)
    Ruling Elder (PCA)
    Pastoral Intern serving at Calvary Presbyterian Church, (PCA)
    Greenville, SC

  2. #2
    Knoxienne's Avatar
    Knoxienne is offline. Puritanboard Graduate
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Posts
    3,645
    One objection I've heard is that the psalms are insufficient to tell us about Christ, since they are in the OT. Also that we should not be singing impreccatory psalms because we are under grace.
    Toni Cunningham, Wife of Bill (Theognome)
    Parkwoods OPC, Overland Park KS


    "Vice is a monster of so frightful mien, As, to be hated, needs but to be seen; Yet seen too oft, familiar with her face, We first endure, then pity, then embrace." ~ Alexander Pope

  3. #3
    Theognome's Avatar
    Theognome is offline. Burrito Bill
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Posts
    3,263
    (Can she bake a cherry pie, Billy Boy)

    Break their teeth in their mouths, oh, God, oh God, Break their teeth in their mouths, oh God...

    Hmmm...

    Theognome
    Bill Cunningham
    Covenant Reformed Church, URC
    Kansas City
    There are three kinds of people- those who can count, and those who can't.

  4. #4
    PresbyDane's Avatar
    PresbyDane is offline. Puritanboard Doctor
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Posts
    6,644
    Martin - Reformed
    Husband to the most godly, honorable and loyal wife Line
    Father of Josva David and Aron Hoseas
    Skive Bykirke - evangelisk luthersk frimenighed
    Webpage www.5solas.dk
    Free Online Reformed Seminary - http://www.tnars.net
    Soli Deo Gloria

  5. #5
    Kim G's Avatar
    Kim G is offline. Puritanboard Junior
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    1,763
    Do you mean objections to singing Psalms at all, or objections to singing only Psalms?

    One objection I can think of is that the Psalms that are set to music are often paraphrases of the Psalm so that they will rhyme, and you are not singing the inspired text but rather thoughts.
    Kim G
    Mitchell Road Presbyterian Church
    Greenville, SC

    Teach me Your way, O LORD; I will walk in Your truth; Unite my heart to fear Your name.
    Psalm 86:11

  6. #6
    Leslie is offline. Puritanboard Junior
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    1,592
    Another objection is that it strikes inquirers who have had some church background as strange. Although seeker-friendly churches go overboard and dilute the gospel, some policies of appeal to inquirers is legitimate. Although I prefer traditional hymns and psalms myself, I think that churches should have music that reflects the tastes of young people. Those of us who are older need to put up with it, not hard when one has the joy of seeing the young folks embracing the gospel.
    Mary Vanderkooi
    Kale Heywott Church (KHC)
    Soddo, Ethiopia

  7. #7
    re4med's Avatar
    re4med is offline. Puritanboard Freshman
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    337
    Quote Originally Posted by Kim G View Post
    Do you mean objections to singing Psalms at all, or objections to singing only Psalms?

    I guess the answer is BOTH since I have experienced both in my conversations with people (even in my own local church).
    William F. Hill, Jr.
    Calvary Presbyterian Church, (PCA)
    Student at Greenville Presbyterian Theological Seminary
    Under care of Calvary Presbytery (PCA)
    Ruling Elder (PCA)
    Pastoral Intern serving at Calvary Presbyterian Church, (PCA)
    Greenville, SC

  8. #8
    ubermadchen's Avatar
    ubermadchen is offline. Puritanboard Outlaw
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Posts
    647
    Quote Originally Posted by Leslie View Post
    Another objection is that it strikes inquirers who have had some church background as strange. Although seeker-friendly churches go overboard and dilute the gospel, some policies of appeal to inquirers is legitimate. Although I prefer traditional hymns and psalms myself, I think that churches should have music that reflects the tastes of young people. Those of us who are older need to put up with it, not hard when one has the joy of seeing the young folks embracing the gospel.
    That's one of the things that has been keeping me from fully embracing EP. Many of the psalms I've heard put to song sound a lot like dirges. The hymns seem more approachable, both musically and lyrically. Right now, I'm trying to find psalms put to a more modern sound because I do think their inclusion in worship is vital.
    Patricia
    Communicant Member
    Zion United Reformed Church
    Ripon, CA

    Give yourself to prayer, to reading and meditation on divine truths: strive to penetrate to the bottom of them and never be content with a superficial knowledge.
    David Brainerd

  9. #9
    Ex Nihilo is offline. Inactive User
    Join Date
    Jul 2004
    Posts
    2,713
    Quote Originally Posted by ubermadchen View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by Leslie View Post
    Another objection is that it strikes inquirers who have had some church background as strange. Although seeker-friendly churches go overboard and dilute the gospel, some policies of appeal to inquirers is legitimate. Although I prefer traditional hymns and psalms myself, I think that churches should have music that reflects the tastes of young people. Those of us who are older need to put up with it, not hard when one has the joy of seeing the young folks embracing the gospel.
    That's one of the things that has been keeping me from fully embracing EP. Many of the psalms I've heard put to song sound a lot like dirges. The hymns seem more approachable, both musically and lyrically. Right now, I'm trying to find psalms put to a more modern sound because I do think their inclusion in worship is vital.
    Many of the psalms in The Book of Psalms for Singing are set to traditional hymn melodies, so maybe that would help!
    Evie B.
    New Members Class, RPCNA, Cambridge, Massachusetts

    [b]Remember not the former things, nor consider the things of old. Behold, I am doing a new thing; now it springs forth, do you not perceive it? I will make a way in the wilderness and rivers in the desert. -- Isaiah 43:18-19 (ESV)[/b]

  10. #10
    NaphtaliPress's Avatar
    NaphtaliPress is offline. Administrator
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    18,185
    Blog Entries
    22
    Folks, this is border line. Keep the thread on the objections to singing Palms period, you've heard; keep EP off the radar or this will get moved, and locked, since we only have two EP threads open for posting right now.
    Chris Coldwell, Lakewood Presbyterian Church (PCA), Dallas, Texas.
    • Naphtali Press: Presbyterian & Reformed Books
    • Westminster Letter Press
    The Confessional Presbyterian Journal
    The Blue Banner Archive
    Calvin in the Hands of the Philistines: Did Calvin Bowl on the Sabbath?
    The Regulative Principle: The Scriptures are the “only infallible rule of faith and practice, no rite or ceremony ought to have a place in the public worship of God, which is not warranted in Scripture, either by direct precept or example, or by good and sufficient inference” (Samuel Miller).
    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Joining PB's Politics & Government Forum

  11. #11
    Skyler's Avatar
    Skyler is offline. Puritanboard Graduate
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Posts
    3,792
    I have no objections to singing psalms. We do it every now and then.

    I don't even have an objection to singing only psalms in worship. Unlike some of my fellow believers, though, I don't see that the Bible limits us to singing psalms in worship. I suspect that's the biggest "real" objection you'll find.
    Jonathan
    Reformed Baptist
    Ohio

    My blog: Middle of the Narrow Way

  12. #12
    Johan's Avatar
    Johan is offline. Puritanboard Freshman
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Posts
    57
    I am really amazed that in reformed circles we question the singing of the psalms. Since this is not a debate the only thing that I will do is to direct you to Calvin's preface to the Genevan Psalter. You can also read Peter Master's "Worship in the melting pot".

    Johan
    Reformed Churches in SA (GKSA)
    South Africa

  13. #13
    NaphtaliPress's Avatar
    NaphtaliPress is offline. Administrator
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    18,185
    Blog Entries
    22
    Folks,
    I'm serious; I'm not going to spend a lot of time deleting more posts. Any more EP related objections or advocacy, this thread is going to get locked.
    Chris Coldwell, Lakewood Presbyterian Church (PCA), Dallas, Texas.
    • Naphtali Press: Presbyterian & Reformed Books
    • Westminster Letter Press
    The Confessional Presbyterian Journal
    The Blue Banner Archive
    Calvin in the Hands of the Philistines: Did Calvin Bowl on the Sabbath?
    The Regulative Principle: The Scriptures are the “only infallible rule of faith and practice, no rite or ceremony ought to have a place in the public worship of God, which is not warranted in Scripture, either by direct precept or example, or by good and sufficient inference” (Samuel Miller).
    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Joining PB's Politics & Government Forum

  14. #14
    he beholds's Avatar
    he beholds is offline. Puritanboard Doctor
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    8,101
    I'm sorry. One of my posts was erased, and that's fine.
    But I wasn't trying to debate and I don't understand this thread. How can we answer the question without giving an objection to the singing of Psalms? What are we supposed to be writing here?
    J.L.



  15. #15
    NaphtaliPress's Avatar
    NaphtaliPress is offline. Administrator
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    18,185
    Blog Entries
    22
    The thread needs to give objections to singing the psalms period, as asked (no debate) not objections to exclusively singing the psalms. Otherwise it is going to get moved and locked.

    Quote Originally Posted by he beholds View Post
    I'm sorry. One of my posts was erased, and that's fine.
    But I wasn't trying to debate and I don't understand this thread. How can we answer the question without giving an objection to the singing of Psalms? What are we supposed to be writing here?
    Chris Coldwell, Lakewood Presbyterian Church (PCA), Dallas, Texas.
    • Naphtali Press: Presbyterian & Reformed Books
    • Westminster Letter Press
    The Confessional Presbyterian Journal
    The Blue Banner Archive
    Calvin in the Hands of the Philistines: Did Calvin Bowl on the Sabbath?
    The Regulative Principle: The Scriptures are the “only infallible rule of faith and practice, no rite or ceremony ought to have a place in the public worship of God, which is not warranted in Scripture, either by direct precept or example, or by good and sufficient inference” (Samuel Miller).
    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Joining PB's Politics & Government Forum

  16. #16
    NaphtaliPress's Avatar
    NaphtaliPress is offline. Administrator
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    18,185
    Blog Entries
    22
    Someone lists objections to eP and someone will want to answer. I've cut off the EP topic. We don't do EP outside the EP forum, and we only have two open threads there right now. List objections you have heard to singing the psalms, not to singing them exclusively.
    If this remains confusing I'm simply going to lock it folks.
    Quote Originally Posted by a mere housewife View Post
    I too am a little confused: I understand the intent of the thread to be not debate, but a listing of objections not just to singing the Psalms but to the EP position (post 7)?
    Chris Coldwell, Lakewood Presbyterian Church (PCA), Dallas, Texas.
    • Naphtali Press: Presbyterian & Reformed Books
    • Westminster Letter Press
    The Confessional Presbyterian Journal
    The Blue Banner Archive
    Calvin in the Hands of the Philistines: Did Calvin Bowl on the Sabbath?
    The Regulative Principle: The Scriptures are the “only infallible rule of faith and practice, no rite or ceremony ought to have a place in the public worship of God, which is not warranted in Scripture, either by direct precept or example, or by good and sufficient inference” (Samuel Miller).
    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Joining PB's Politics & Government Forum

  17. #17
    a mere housewife's Avatar
    a mere housewife is offline. Not your cup of tea
    Join Date
    Apr 2003
    Posts
    6,740
    Thanks Mr. Coldwell: I deleted that post when I saw yours. I think the thread has been a bit confusing because both things were being asked for, and it wasn't clear to me whether answering with EP objections, or going on to argue them, was the issue: it's clear now! :-)
    Heidi
    Steger, IL

    'I cannot live like Jesus, example though he be
    For he was strong and selfless, and I am tied to me.
    But I have asked my Jesus to live his life in me . . .
    Behold his warm, his tangible, his dear humanity.'
    -Betty Stam

  18. #18
    he beholds's Avatar
    he beholds is offline. Puritanboard Doctor
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    8,101
    OK.
    An [possible] objection to singing the Psalms:

    If singing in worship is really a means of prayer, the Psalms only allow you to pray in that powerful way for things that happened before Christ was born--since his birth, no new praises can be sung.

    I hope this is more along the lines of what's asked for in this thread♥
    J.L.



  19. #19
    Prufrock's Avatar
    Prufrock is offline. Arbitrary Moderation
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Posts
    3,223
    As a Psalm-singer, these are the most common objections I've encountered are the following (sorry for any repeats from above). All of them pertain to singing psalms at all, whereas number 2 pertains to singing psalms exclusively.

    1.) The subject matter pertained to a different time and people: an earthly kingdom with its warfare; being under the law; sacrificial worship; etc.

    2.) (Edited out by poster)

    3.) Imprecatory psalms are not appropriate for today.

    4.) They do not mention Jesus, or acts of redemptive history after the time of David.

    5.) They do not fit with our current style and tastes in worship music; or, they are often hard for us to relate to. They are, in a sense, "worshipfully" inferior to modern songs which emphasize what God has done for me.

    6.) They can be obscure and hard to understand. They can lead to the believe that we are saved by works (e.g., Psalm 7). It is not easy to discern Christianity in them.

    7.) They can drive visitors away.

    Edit
    Oops. I just noticed Chris's post above. Number 2 has been edited out, since it was an objection raised against only Psalms.
    Paul
    On "Temporary Leave"
    Please feel free to contact me by Private Message, but please include your email address.

  20. #20
    NaphtaliPress's Avatar
    NaphtaliPress is offline. Administrator
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    18,185
    Blog Entries
    22
    This is an exercise in futility. I think Bill has some answers though. Locking and moving.
    Chris Coldwell, Lakewood Presbyterian Church (PCA), Dallas, Texas.
    • Naphtali Press: Presbyterian & Reformed Books
    • Westminster Letter Press
    The Confessional Presbyterian Journal
    The Blue Banner Archive
    Calvin in the Hands of the Philistines: Did Calvin Bowl on the Sabbath?
    The Regulative Principle: The Scriptures are the “only infallible rule of faith and practice, no rite or ceremony ought to have a place in the public worship of God, which is not warranted in Scripture, either by direct precept or example, or by good and sufficient inference” (Samuel Miller).
    Click to get: Board Rules -- Signature Requirements -- Joining PB's Politics & Government Forum

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72