I grew up in a Southern Presbyterian congregation (PCUS), which is now regrettably part of the PCUSA but retains a certain evangelical flavor. For 47 years, this congregation had a faithful pastor who culturally was more of a Baptist than a Presbyterian. Annual protracted evangelistic services with an altar call were the norm.

Not too many years ago, being the home grown boy, I was invited to preach for this congregation. After the Lord’s Day service, I was asked if I would return to do a “revival” for them.

I outlined what I would do, including that I would not extend a invitation in the form of an altar call. I explained the reason I objected to an altar call, suggested they read Iain Murray’s The Invitation System, and offered solicit information cards from prospective inquirers, hold pre and post service meetings, visit individuals in their homes.

After some consideration, the session of the church withdrew their invitation for me to conduct the meetings.

I suggest any attempt to change such practices be grounded in teaching the Regulative Principle, that practice as well as doctrine must be rooted in explicit warrant in God’s word. Also, in considering a subsequent call, make clear one’s stand on such issues. This will limit the congregations willing to call you; but may make for a less contentious ministry after you are on the field. If you do try to make the shift in your current pastorate, start with your deacons and other unofficial leadership in the congregation. Make clear you believe in evangelism and the free offer of the gospel (assuming you do) and your continuing desire to evangelize the lost. Get them thinking about how they do evangelism outside of regular public worship.

__________________
Glenn Ferrell
Pastor, Sovereign Redeemer Presbyterian Church
OPC
Boise, Idaho