04-26-2008, 09:33 AM
|
 | Puritanboard Postgraduate | | Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Wrightwood, CA
Posts: 4,266
Thanks: 1,458
Thanked 337 Times in 201 Posts
| |
Quote:
Originally Posted by HaigLaw  Quote:
Originally Posted by Stephen Quote:
Originally Posted by HaigLaw There is nothing in the WCOF denigrating speaking in tongues. The closest thing is in the worship section saying all prayer uttered in a worship service must be in a known tongue. If there were, it would violate Paul's injunction not to prohibit speaking in tongues.
All the cessationist arguments I have studied have been found wanting. The strongest one, which I used to accept, is that tongues presume to be new revelation, and thus violate a closed canon, until a friend pointed out to me that none of the instances of tongues recorded in the Bible contained any revelatory material.  | Sorry, but your friend is mistaken. I would research the matter yourself before listening to what someone told you. Tongues, healing, and prophecy were always connected with revelation. Your position is outside of Reformed orthodoxy. The classical position that Reformed people affirm is upheld by Hodge, Warfield, and many of the great systematicians. The book entitiled, Whatever Happened to The Reformation by Johnson and White shows the classic position. Edward Irving, who introduced much of the modern tongues and prophecy movement, was removed from the ministry in the Presbyterian Church in the middle 1800's for this position. | I would have to question this as Pastor KMK has above. The inference that I have not studied this myself is unfounded in what I said. I'm a sola scriptura man. Show me from Scripture that tongues have ceased. Or show me from the Westminster Standards that I am "outside of Reformed orthodoxy."
All of the cessationist arguments I've read reason from excesses, not from Scripture or the standards. | These are some interesting threads that interact with charismata and the WCF: Rutherford, The Gift of Prophecy, and the WCF Cessationist or no? Why?#2
__________________  |