Quote:
Originally Posted by DMcFadden  Chris,
I don't really have much to argue with you about on this one. I agree with you and Dr. Clark on Reformed and Calvinist, but probably not on "Calvinistic" for the very reason you cited. When Harvard hired a Unitarian to teach theology in 1805 that pretty well said it all for "Calvinism" at Harvard. Baptists in America and England carried a lot of water for the cause when others were apostasizing. |
I had Harvard in mind when I noted New England. The situation wasn't the same in the rest of the USA and certainly isn't applicable to the Old School Presbyterians in either the North or the South, whatever their other failings were. Harvard was founded by Puritans, but they weren't Presbyterians, they were Congregationalists. I find that people often conflate the two and have the idea that the Pilgrims were Presbyterians.
Some of the Southern Baptist Founders like James P. Boyce and Basil Manly studied under Charles Hodge at Princeton Seminary.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DMcFadden And, as the example of John Frame has proven, there is no unanimity in the conservative branch of the Reformed community even on the meaning and application of the RPW. Second, look at the crazies in the PCUSA or CRC. They were my profs in seminary and taught me that the WCF was misguided, that the Princetonians were flat out wrong about the "novelty" of inerrancy, and that ordaining gays is OK. Frankly, I'd take a Dever's or Piper's Calvinistic theology over that stuff anyday! |
You'll find no agreement with John Frame here among any who hold to the RPW whether they are EP or not. It seems to me that Prof. Frame says that so he can justify his allowance for drama, dance, etc. He says there is no agreement and then he redefines it in a way that is unrecognizable.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DMcFadden So, no whining here. I'm baptist not Reformed. But, there is more in common between PB baptists and PB Reformed folks than either of us and the majority of the "Reformed" in America and Europe today. |
Agreed.