Quote:
Originally Posted by biblicalthought  Quote: |
If two arguments have the *same form,* then, if both arguments have true premises, then the conclusins would both be true.
| This is why I questioned you regarding your premise.
Please, PM, re-read my question regarding your premise. |
I have read your post.
You simply don't understand my argument.
I showed that I gave an argument *with the same form* and *with the same numer of true premises*, but you rejected my conclusion.
So, you can't say my argument was invalid---since it was an instance of MP.
So, you must say I had a false premise.
Since [2*] was stipulated true, then [1] must be the false premise.
If [1] was false in my argument, it was false in my portrayal of Morey's argument,
Thus Morey's argument was unsound.
Please, re-read my post, if you've studied logic you should understand it. read it a couple times if you need to.