01-29-2008, 08:56 AM
|
| Puritanboard Freshman | | Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Hammondsville, Ohio
Posts: 208
Thanks: 12
Thanked 33 Times in 22 Posts
| |
Quote:
Originally Posted by BaptistInCrisis  Quote:
Originally Posted by SueS Expository preaching vs. topical is a bit too simplistic for my tastes. Can't a topical sermon be preached in an expository manner?
Correct me if I'm wrong, but in my experience a topical sermon is one that is built around the opinions of the speaker, ie, on divorce, raising children, the evils of ipods, etc. The focus is on what the speaker thinks and Scripture is only used as a support for his views - proof-texting at its worst - and falls under the category of man-centred moralism where the congregation is told what it must do (law) rather than what Christ has done (grace). It becomes a matter of obedience to authority as a work rather than obedience to Christ out of gratitude for what He has done. It does incredible spiritual damage to those who sit under this form of teaching. | Sue, I think it depends on how topical is defined. Lets say I want to teach on baptism (the example I gave earlier). If I just pick passages to support my particular view of baptism I am doing what you are saying, offering my opinions. But if I am dealing with the text then I am preaching in an expository manner. To be certain I have definite opinions about what I am preaching, but what preacher doesn't?
I have seen some miserable topical preaching. For example: in order to prove that Christians should witness the following three points are offered:
1. The prophets proclaimed God's word so we should witness.
2. Jesus proclaimed God's word so we should witness.
3. The Apostles proclaimed God's word so we should witness.
Of course each point is replete with supporting verses. It may make for a great talk and may even inspire some to go out and share their faith, but is a travesty of the pulpit. |
Oh, I agree fully - what you are describing is what topical preaching should be - an exposition on a particular subject. When done properly it is a great way to get across a message. But.....much of what is called topical preaching is what I experienced first hand in my former church and it ain't pretty. I think we are talking about two ends of the same spectrum.
|