Why did the early Church never think of it? Zeal to win the lost is commendable but needs to be informed by Scripture. May I suggest a careful study of Romans 1:16f. and 1.Cor.1:18ff. ?!
The Gospel must be preached and lived. The Greek word for a play actor is a word from which we derive 'hypocrite'!
We may and must learn from the history of the Church in times of great blessing - preaching with the Holy Spirit sent from heaven is what is again so desperately needed. Better men - not better methods. 'A holy man is a mighty weapon in the hand out God - my people need my holiness' (I am citing from memory the words of a Scottish divine).

__________________
Independent Reformed Baptist Church (NE England, nr. Durham)