Evie,
This is an excellent idea. I don't have time to offer much in the way of a thoughtful critique at the moment but when my busy schedule lightens up I hope to chip in my

I spent some time studying Elliott in college and wrote a paper on
The Wasteland. Later, I read
Murder in the Cathedral. He is a powerful and challenging read.
BTW, I would also be interested in Reformed perspectives on some Puritan-Anglican poems that I have posted about previously
here and
here and
here if anyone is inclined.